Top 5 current tuscl contibutors

Is there some "basis" on how we should rank them ?

No

Papi and Shaillyn are the only two who come to mind. Both would be terrific moderators. Shaillyn left.

shadowcat
Subraman
Papi_Chulo
Call.Me.Ishael
founder

Here are 5 in no particular order :

- Papi Chulo
- 25
- Wallanon
- LondonGuy
- doctorevil

"... Note of warning: Post any bullshit and you will lose your VIP membership indefinitely ..."

Well in that case:

1) Founder
2) Founder
3) Founder
4) Founder
5) Founder

I would say it would have to be someone that posts regularly, and is pretty even keeled (does not get into flame-wars all the time):

Off the top of my head:

- shadowcat
- subraman
- georgemicrodong
- jackslash
- doctorevil

Do not include me in the list

shadowcat
Subraman
Papi_Chulo
Cashman
warrior15

The I’d have to add lopaw. And lest someone question that, a female customer’s perspective is invaluable.

Papi_Chulo
sinclair
PaulDrake
Subraman
MackTruck (NOT a BS answer. If anyone challenges it, I’ll explain it outside this thread)

Depends if we are ranking by individual account or IP address...

Subraman
Papi
Huntsman
Wallanon

I know that's just four. It's all I'm coming up with right now. I'll add a fifth if a name jumps out at me.

A lot of good ones but these taught me a lot

Papi_Chulo
Subraman
twentyfive
shailynn (funny as fuck where’s he at?)
rickdugan

Yeah... PaulDrake is solid.

Papi
Shadowcat
Jackslash
Shailynn if he is around

Without knowing what this for, here goes.

NPO

Papi chulo
Shadowcat
Pauldrake
Skibum
Warrior15

Honorable mentions

TFP
25
Rickdugan
Subraman

Shadow
Papi
Subra
Doc evil
Tie 25 & George micro

Papi C
Shadowcat
Rick Dugan
Call me Ismael
Subraman

2 HM (because I didn’t see them mentioned yet)

JohnSmith69
Gawker

Big time characters and great stories

Contributors or posters?

Shadowcat
Lopaw
Rick Dugan
Steeldog65
Skibum609

Notable Mention to 2 that have moved on:

Yoda57
FarmerArt

Shadowcat
Rick Dugan
Papi Chulo
George Microdong
Lopaw
Wallanon

(Sorry, can’t count...)

With all due respect. Being on the site a long time or participating a lot doesn't make someone a model TUSCL member.

These lists are more like a popularity contest. Some of the people listed can be argued to contribute negatively.

On the other hand we have individuals like SJG who contribute a lot to the site but are not as popular because certain cliques may not like them.

If these lists have to go with potential "moderation" then get ready for the site to turn into an echo chamber. Many of those listed need moderation rather than be relied on to enforce it.

With all due respect. Being on the site a long time or participating a lot doesn't make someone a model TUSCL member.

These lists are more like a popularity contest. Some of the people listed can be argued to contribute negatively.

On the other hand we have individuals like SJG who contribute a lot to the site but are not as popular because certain cliques may not like them.

If these lists have to go with potential "moderation" then get ready for the site to turn into an echo chamber. Many of those listed need moderation rather than be relied on to enforce it.

Off the top of my head:
Shadowcat
Papi
Nicespice
Blondebombshell
Warrior15
There are many others, but those are the first five that came up in a Rorschach test kind of way based in recent postings

Keep it on topic

I didn't ask for comments, only names

I appreciate many but if I had to pick just five, I'd list:

Papi
Call.me.Ishmael
Doc Evil
Jack Slash
Nicespice

25
Subraman
MisterWonderful
Call.Me.Ishmael
PaulDrake

Papi Chulo
Subraman
Call.Me.Ishmael
Warrior 15
Lopaw

Shadowcat
NiceSpice
Papi_Chulo
doctorevil
Subraman

Shadowcat
Clubber
Papi Chiulo
Subraman
Rick Dugan
Nina Bambina
Motörhead

Hard to pick just 5 as I think there are a lot of great contributors.

Papi Chulo
Call.Me.Ishmael
doctorevil
tahoecruz
Pizza

My last two choices were folks who contribute more on my general area.

In no particular order:

lopaw
Papi
April9424
wallanon
georgemicrodong

@founder ask why everyone picked the ones they did

25, I think the question was top contributors...vs posters...that was how I chose.

This is a popularity contest. Nothing more.

Keep it on topic

2 members have already lost VIP for not following directions

Papi chulo
Shadowcat
Jackslash
Sinclair
Evil phd

Papi
Shadowcat
Sinclair
Juice
Nicespice

Papi
Subraman
georgmicrodong
lopaw
Call.Me.Ishmael

Honorable Mention:
MisterWonderful
PaulDrake

shadowcat
Subraman
Papi_Chulo
georgemicrodong
wallanon

Shadowcat
Papi
Subraman
Call me Ishmael
Flagoneer

Papi
Jackslash
DrEvil
Blond Bombshell
Waffle

shadowcat
Papi_Chulo
Subraman
rickdugan
wallanon

This discussion is like asking who the most eligible woman is on “The Bachelor”? In fact all you got is a bunch of attractive losers. Who has time to take off 4-5 months from their jobs/life to go on a reality show? That answer is basically somebody who has nothing going on in their life. Most of the valuable contributors move on to better things and get burnt out from all the repetitive stupidity. The reviews for VIP commenters is where it’s at.

Sinclair
Papi_Chulo
shadowcat
jackslash
Subraman

IceyLoco
DC9428
SanJoseGuy
Nicole94
Liwet

Papi chulo
Wallanon
Sinclair
Shadowcat
Subraman

Shadowcat and papi chulo is the 2 most respected members that would serve this site well

Can't think of anyothers that fit that Bill

Thats my votes

John Smith would make that list.. He just needs to be more active but besides that he is well loved and respected as well

Jacklash would make that list assm well as he 2 seems loved and respected.

Wallen dosent post much but has served the site well with a crazy amount of reviews. He also seems respect and loved by the majority.

I think any of those men have and will continue to do this site well.

Hope that helps founder

Shadowcat
Dr. Evil
Papi
BlondBombshell
Nicespice
EastCoaster
Jackslash

shadowcat
Papi_Chulo
wallanon
sinclair
jackslash

Papi
Shadowcat
Subraman
Warrior 15
Juicebox

PaulDrake
CallMeIshmael
Papi
Subraman
OWG

Papi chulo
Shadowcat
Subraman
lopaw
Call.Me.Ishmael

In no particular order:
Shadowcat
Wallanon
Reverendhornibastard
25
Nina
Nicespice

Thinking about it a bit more I need to add
Nice Spice
Warrenboy
Even though he’s no longer with us I have very fond memories of Farmer Art I aspire to behave like him I always thought he was a classy guy

Papi chulo
Shadowcat
Sinclair
Skibum609
Blondebombshell

Shadowcat
Papi_Chulo
lopaw
jackslash
JohnSmith69

Shadowcat
Sinclair
Rickdugan
Gorge micro
Papi chulo

Other than wallanon:

shadowcat
sinclair
Papi_Chulo
EveHartley
lopaw

Papi
TFP
Tahoecruz
NJBella
Georgemicrodong

No particular order

Jackslash
PapiChulo
TwentyFive
Shadowcat
Nicespice

Going by actual contributions and excluding a popularity contest or thinking with my dick..

RickDugan, he catches much flak but has several reviews and offers thoughtful insights.
Wallanon, mainly for his amazing and varied amount of reviews.

There are others in varying degrees but those two instantly popped into my mind as the actual top contributors.

Subraman
Shadowcat
Warrior 15
Cashman
Twentyfive

Shaillyn would have been on the list if he is still around --he doesn't post but it doesn't mean he isn't still lurking.

The only feedback you asked for is names so....

In alphabetical order:
April
Blonde bombshell
Nice spice
Ninabambina
Pole dancer

Honorable mention (against by strongest PL instincts)
Papi_chulo
(Pl take as highest compliment papi, you are right behind the hottest hotties)

In a future survey from founder, i’d Like below 5 to rise as top contributors:
Bj99
Judy Judy
Linziedeet
Missdevonshire
Strippercutie

Shadowcat
Subraman
Papi Chulo
Call.Me.Ishmael
Jackslash

Shadowcat
Papi
Juice
Doctor Evil
Nice Spice

Shadowcat
Papi
25
Subra
RBD-- the system is gold

*******

Jackslash
Shailynn
JamesSD
Juice
Ninabambina
Nice spice

Wallanon
Papi
Shadowcat
Call. Me Ishamel
lowpaw (not the most frequent poster but I really enjoy the perspective that she offers)

Now, I'd love to see how our subjective rankings line up with the actual number of reviews, discussions and comments, probably adjusted to reflect average annual contributions.

Papi Chulo
Subraman
ShadowCat
Jackslash
JohnSmith69

Here is my five

Nicespice
Juicebox69 because he endured a lot of mockery and stayed with it.
FarmerArt was awesome
SlickSpic was funny as hell I miss him
Papi Chulo\

Honorable mention Motorhead

shadowcat
Subraman
Papi_Chulo
georgmicrodong
doctorevil

Papi-chulo
Nicespice
Blonde bombshell
?
?

Papi-chulo
Nicespice
Blonde bombshell
?
?

Honorable mention Motorhead plus one Joe

Amen

Shadowcat
Papi Chulo
Sinclair
MrDeuce
Call.Me.Ishmael

wtf ever did happen to shailynn and JS69?
They would have been on my list if they hadnt disappeared.

I don’t know about Shailynn but JS69 posts once in a while. I think JS69 just settled down with a civvie and is done with dream strippers. Good for him.

Papi Chulo
Shadowcat
Lopaw
John Smith69
Slickspit
Ski bum 609

Papi
Shadow
Lopaw
subraman
mrdeuce

"Note of warning: Post any bullshit and you will lose your VIP membership indefinitely."

Well, damn.

Papi Chulo
shadowcat
jackslash
doctorevil
juice

My five...

reverendhornibastard
gawker
NJBalla
OldWhiteGuy
nicespice

Got thrown off by this thread - it's more than 6-months old

nicespice should not be in the conversation b/c her having a vagina gives her an unfair advantage

I posted a link to this thread on Crazyjoe's thread in the front room. I thought it was relevant.

Oldwhiteguy

Sanjoseguy
Nicole
Papi chulo
Gawker
Reverend horny bastard

txtittyfag

^

"Note of warning: Post any bullshit and you will lose your VIP membership indefinitely."

Mack Truck
Txtittyfag
L1oydSchoene
Randummember(because every league needs a cellar dweller)
Your momma!