Who'd You Rather: Salma Hayek vs. Kate Upton
Time for the third round and let's start it off with what I think is the most anticipated matchup. One could make the case this is the biggest matchup of the bracket thus far — maybe the biggest matchup we'll have in the bracket as a whole when it's all said and done.
Distinctly different styles. Both very popular ladies.
Also, as we enter a new round, we add more, uh, "sample material": Another picture & clip for each lady.
Only one can win, and as a reminder to those new to this, "both" is not an option (even if saying that doesn't stop bang69 whatsoever) — you have to pick who you prefer or abstain. Here we go.
Celebrity Bracket: Salma HAYEK vs. Kate UPTON
Salma HAYEK
36C-24-36
ROUND 1: Def. Jenny McCARTHY, 27-4, /discussion.php
ROUND 2: Def. Denise RICHARDS, 28-9, /discussion.php
PIC 1: /photo.php
PIC 2: www.xdressy.com
PIC 3: peopledotcom.files.wordpress.com
CLIP 1: (sexy dancing) www.youtube.com
CLIP 2: (kinda sexy dancing) www.youtube.com
CLIP 3: (stripping) www.youtube.com
Hayek is currently the odds-on favorite to take the whole bracket, and one could make a case Upton might be her biggest challenge before the ultimate championship round. She clearly has fans, she's won both of her matchups by a wide margin and has garnered more votes than anyone in the bracket. That said, she's not necessarily everyone's flavor, plus, I suppose it's plausible one could evaluate their spouse choices and say Hayek (one of the world's richest men) might be more gold-digger-ish than Upton (still a rich guy, but a more down-to-earth baseball player). In short, she's clearly one of the world's sexiest women, but so is Upton. She's earned the crown of favorite, but this is no guarantee.
Kate UPTON
34DD-28-36
ROUND 1: Def. Lisa GUERRERO, 14-7-2, /discussion.php
ROUND 2: Def. Rebecca ROMIJN, 20-14, /discussion.php
PIC 1: /photo.php
PIC 2: images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com
PIC 3: d9nvuahg4xykp.cloudfront.net
CLIP 1: (bikini & wet T-shirt) www.youtube.com
CLIP 2: (swimsuit modeling) www.youtube.com
CLIP 3: (bikini flirting) www.youtube.com
Upton becomes the next to step up to the plate against the powerhouse Hayek. After a bit of a tussle with a more-popular-than-expected Lisa Guerrero, Upton found her footing against fellow SI cover model Rebecca Romijn. What does she have going for her? Well, as is the case in most comparisons with Upton, she's bustier, has the California vibe and is more of a combination of hot and cute than Hayek, who can be cute and funny but is so scorching that she even made the relatively tame-looking Frida Kahlo seem hot. However, Upton is your typical blonde, and voters have leaned heavily brunette, with Hayek being the flag-bearing standard. Can Upton compete? There's only one way to find out.
Alright, gentlemen (and ladies). Let's have it out and see what happens.
HAYEK
or UPTON
Comments
last commentUpton
Log in to vote
Hayek.
Log in to vote
Hayek for me!
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Tough call they are two of my favorites but in her prime Hayek wins for me.
Hayek.
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Hayek.
Log in to vote
Upton
Log in to vote
Hayak when she was in Dogma.
Log in to vote
Upton
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
This is a dilemma. I am picturing both of them at their most desirable moment. Upton by a (blonde) hair.
Log in to vote
I can only credit mass blindness caused by excessive boobage for Upton's win over Romijn.
Hayek. At least with her, the tits, while impressive, don't outshine her gorgeous face.
Log in to vote
Can't find anything wrong with Kate Upton, but she is not in the same league as Salma Hayek in my worldly view.
Hayek it is..
Log in to vote
Hayek.
Log in to vote
Salma HAYEK
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Upton
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Being from Detroit, I have to vote for Justin Verlanders wife.
Katie Upton.
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Salma
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
There's only two chicks left in this tourney I'd rather bang than Salma Hayek. One of them is Kate UPTON.
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Both extremely hot. Both eminently doable. But since I can’t vote for both, by bite goes to...
Upton
Log in to vote
And my vote, too. Lol
Log in to vote
Salma Hayek!
Log in to vote
Hayek.
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Upton, but that's a super difficult choice.
Log in to vote
This is getting hard, real close, but Hayek.
Log in to vote
Hayek
Log in to vote
Hayek. Upton is a hottie and a SI swimsuit covergirl - but Hayek is still hotter!
Log in to vote
Time to close 'er up.
The Hayek train rolls on, and it's getting more and more difficult to see how she gets stopped.
I, for one, like big ol' boobs, and Kate Upton has 'em. So I'll toss her one more vote. But I'm only one man, so it won't be enough.
HAYEK: 26
UPTON: 11
̶B̶u̶l̶l̶z̶e̶y̶e̶'̶s̶ ̶b̶i̶t̶e̶:̶ ̶1̶
̶S̶o̶m̶e̶o̶n̶e̶ ̶w̶a̶n̶t̶s̶ ̶a̶ ̶s̶a̶n̶d̶w̶i̶c̶h̶:̶ ̶1̶
Hayek wins again. Granted, the percentage of the vote she's garnered has gone down from round to round (87.1 against Jenny McCarthy, 75.7 against Denise Richards and 70.3 against Upton), but her vote totals have remained untouchable throughout (27 first round, 28 second round, 26 third round; the only other winner that's approached that has been Gianna Michaels with 23). The other Celebrity semi may just be to find out who the runner-up is in this bracket. That said, Michaels may — may — loom in the championship, and that's enough of a contrast of styles that maybe Gianna puts up a fight. But this is definitely looking like Hayek's tournament to lose moreso than anyone else's to win.
Nonetheless, we'll keep going because, well, it's still fun to compare and you never know what'll happen.
Log in to vote
I thought it would have been much closer if not Upton winning (given she had a strong previous round against good competition)
Log in to vote
... [shrug]. There's a sizable, loyal Hayek following here, and in general. That's become clear. I think she's kind of the choice of a generation, namely one that was at prime media-consuming age between Desperado (1995) and Ugly Betty (2006-10).
Furthermore, our sample seems to be a little anti-blonde. Add it up and you're getting what you're getting.
I'm fine with there being a clear winner. The votes are bearing it out.
Log in to vote
A better matchup would be Salma Hayek vs. Rosario Dawson. Battle of the hot Latinas!
Log in to vote
Rosario is fine but not even on the same sexy planet as Salma.
Log in to vote
The next bracket — whenever we have it (maybe 2021) — will have a crowdsourcing component when it comes to picking the ladies. Hold onto your Dawson idea. I'd be open to working her into our next competition, whenever it may be.
Log in to vote
As if today, Kate Upton.
I would pick Salma in her prime 15-20 yes ago. As she's in her early 50's now.
Log in to vote
^ you are supposed to compare the 2 while both in their prime
Log in to vote
This is a tough one, but Hayek
Log in to vote
Going head-to-head, each on the best day of her entire career, Salma Hayek would win easily.
Today, present day, I'd go with Kate Upton. There is no escaping the slow decay of time
Log in to vote
Yeah - the precincts are closed!
Log in to vote