ListingsWhat's NearbyReviewsWhat's NewTop 40ArticlesDiscussionsForumsUnpublished ReviewsUnpublished ArticlesLog Out
start a discussion

Would you pay more potato saled with pickles, or without?

avatar for herbtcat
herbtcat
Cool Cat in the Valley
As long as we discussing stupid, race baiting questions and posts, I want to wrestle with this critically important question:

Do you prefer your potato salad to have chopped pickles or no chopped pickles. If you go into a deli or sandwich shop that has many types of salad, and they had both types of potato salad, would you offer less money for the salad without pickles, or with more. Please support your position with objective data so we know you take this matter seriously.

And...………………… discuss!

17 comments

Jump to latest
avatar for shadowcat
shadowcat
•
5 years ago
I've never seen chopped pickles in potato salad. One of my signature dishes is potato salad and I would never consider adding pickles to it. Now I do like pickle relish on my hot dog and would pay extra for it.
avatar for Jascoi
Jascoi
•
5 years ago
give me more chopped pickles and sum spice.
avatar for ATACdawg
ATACdawg
•
5 years ago
Pickles in my potato salad? Never!

Now, radish slices on the other hand.....
avatar for MackTruck
MackTruck
•
5 years ago
Smart talk. I will remember this
avatar for datinman
datinman
•
5 years ago
Pickles or no pickles I can deal with. Not a fan of potato salad that is sour and warm (German style).
avatar for Funkycold88
Funkycold88
•
5 years ago
Never seen anybody put chopped pickles in potato salad. Personally I don't like potato salad anyways so I'll just have to pass on this one.
avatar for Cashman1234
Cashman1234
•
5 years ago
Isn’t potato salad sold by weight? Then you are already paying more for the pickles - as they add more weight to the overall salad.

I’m not going to pay more. If they have traditional or potato salad with pickles - and the prices differ - I’ll take the cheaper of the two.
avatar for Huntsman
Huntsman
•
5 years ago
No to the pickles in potato salad. Some chopped celery and chives are a nice addition though.
avatar for gawker
gawker
•
5 years ago
I don’t care whether there pickles in my potato salad or not. Just DON’T add hard boiled eggs. You might as well just put sulpher in it.
avatar for SirLapdancealot
SirLapdancealot
•
5 years ago
@Cashman it depends on the density of pickles vs 'tato salad. Just nitpickling you, bro.
avatar for Cashman1234
Cashman1234
•
5 years ago
SirLDAlot - I agree - as you are correct. Potatoes are quite dense - and those pickles aren’t so dense. Of course nothing is as dense as SJG...
avatar for MackTruck
MackTruck
•
5 years ago
Yes, pickles are extra
avatar for Cashman1234
Cashman1234
•
5 years ago
MockTruck wants his pickles in the tailpipe - not in his salads...
avatar for Call.Me.Ishmael
Call.Me.Ishmael
•
5 years ago
I don't pay differently based on pickles.
avatar for rickthevulture
rickthevulture
•
5 years ago
Potato salad is gross. Just kill something like a possum or armadillo or a moronic hairless ape an let it sit by the side of the road for a few days. Pickles or no pickles it’ll be yummy yummy yummy in my tummy tummy tummy! Squawk!!!
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
•
5 years ago
I think this is some kind of code for something hey OP please clarify.
avatar for herbtcat
herbtcat
•
5 years ago
@twentyfive... no need for clarification from me. You guys got this. :p
You must be a member to leave a comment.Join Now