Who'd You Rather: Rebecca Romijn vs. Kate Upton

avatar for AnonymousJim
AnonymousJim
Scanning the room from the back
"Hello there, children!"

"Hi, Chef."

Sorry I had to step away from the forum for a while, gentlemen of gentlemen's clubs. Sometimes, business comes up you have to deal with, even though you don't want to deal with it. Nothing you or I can do.

That said, I think it's mostly taken care of and we should be able charge toward crowning a 2019 "Who'd You Rather" champion, though we'll take time off for Thanksgiving, no doubt.

We only have two more second-round matchups yet, and we get back to better business here with one of them, our final Round-of-32 matchup in the Celebrity Bracket.

---

Celebrity Bracket: Rebecca ROMIJN vs. Kate UPTON

---

Rebecca ROMIJN

34B-25-36

ROUND 1: Def. Candice MICHELLE, 16-3-1

PIC 1: https://www.tuscl.net/photo.php?id=1954
PIC 2: http://geekshizzle.com/wp-content/upload…

CLIP 1: (topless striptease) https://www.pornhub.com/view_video.php?v…
CLIP 2: (swimsuit modeling) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Kk9npxq…

---

Romijn had an easy time of it in the first round, as GoDaddy Girl and WWE Diva Candice Michelle's somewhat exaggerated features were no match for Romijn's statuesque and natural figure. Romijn's a threat in a lot of different ways. She's got model looks that have put her on the cover of Sports Illustrated's Swimsuit Edition twice, and while she was the first SI model to get the bodypaint treatment, she's better known for wearing the blue paint and bodysuit required of the Mystique character in X-Men movies. She's even started making the leap into more serious roles. Smart, beautiful and versatile, it's no surprise Romijn was a popular choice in her first showdown.

---

Kate UPTON

34DD-28-36

ROUND 1: Def. Lisa GUERRERO, 14-7-2

PIC 1: https://www.tuscl.net/photo.php?id=1955
PIC 2: https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/…

CLIP 1: (bikini & wet T-shirt) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XOrjV7vJ…
CLIP 2: (swimsuit modeling) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JzOn_Cp…

---

So what's better than appearing on the cover of the SI Swimsuit Edition twice? How about three times? Romijn may have gotten there in 1999 and 2006 (we should maybe call it one and a half since the '06 edition had eight ladies on it), but Upton was on the cover in 2012, '13 and '17, joining Christie Brinkley, Cheryl Tiegs, Elle Macpherson, Kathy Ireland and Tyra Banks in the elite three-timers club. Mrs. Justin Verlander isn't the actress Romijn is, but she has appeared in a few films. She also got past a popular Lisa Guerrero in the last round. Ultimately, it's what you prefer: Curves or more-toned? Girl next door or the classy model? If you said "the first one" to either question, Upton's it.

---

This feels like an all-timer. Hey, if you've gotta pick, picking from SI cover models isn't a bad way to go. Hard to go wrong here.

ROMIJN
or UPTON

35 comments

Jump to latest
avatar for JAprufrock
JAprufrock
5 years ago
This one is hard, much like my cock after seeing photos of both babes.

Upton.
avatar for AnonymousJim
AnonymousJim
5 years ago
Two outstanding comments to lead this off.

I missed you guys.
avatar for anthony6613
anthony6613
5 years ago
Upton
avatar for rh48hr
rh48hr
5 years ago
I'll go with UPTON, but I would change my vote if I was going to bed with mystique!
avatar for Muddy
Muddy
5 years ago
Romijn
avatar for wallanon
wallanon
5 years ago
When UPTON is in swimsuit model shape she's a tough out. She's got my vote for this round.
avatar for Warrior15
Warrior15
5 years ago
Romjin. That second video is hilarious.
avatar for grand1511
grand1511
5 years ago
Upton
avatar for Heellover
Heellover
5 years ago
Upton
avatar for IHearVoices
IHearVoices
5 years ago
Not really a fan of either, but I'll go with Romijn.
avatar for Cashman1234
Cashman1234
5 years ago
Not a fan of either. I’m going with Upton. But that’s only because Romijn fucked John Stamos...
avatar for gammanu95
gammanu95
5 years ago
Romijn is one of the very few women who could beat out Upton, but she does.
avatar for bullzeye
bullzeye
5 years ago
These are getting harder.

Pun intended

UPTON
avatar for jackslash
jackslash
5 years ago
Kate. But what about a 3-way?
avatar for pistola
pistola
5 years ago
Kate.

Essentially a tie for me, but the cat daddy dance lady wins.
avatar for Call.Me.Ishmael
Call.Me.Ishmael
5 years ago
Upton
avatar for Stephanie4life
Stephanie4life
5 years ago
Rebecca all the way!
avatar for Jascoi
Jascoi
5 years ago
ever so slightly a bit more for romijn.t
avatar for Papi_Chulo
Papi_Chulo
5 years ago
I love Upton's tits but not much else and she seems very airhead-ish.

Upton for w/e reason rubs me the wrong-way so gonna go with ROMIJN more so as a vote against Upton.
avatar for joatmon
joatmon
5 years ago
Upton
avatar for prevert
prevert
5 years ago
I’m apparently in the minority here, but ROMIJN by a mile, even considering Upton’s gorgeous tits. Sorry Kate.
avatar for ime
ime
5 years ago
upton
avatar for ATACdawg
ATACdawg
5 years ago
Aaaaarrrrgggghhh! I can't choose.

....but if I have to, I'll go for Kate for her girl I wish lived next door face and her gorgeous boobs.
avatar for mjx01
mjx01
5 years ago
Rebecca ROMIJN
avatar for rl27
rl27
5 years ago
Romijn.

she’s hotter than Upton,but the part that did it for me was Louis Armstrong walking on the moon giving me that Bluto in Animal House vibe. don’t know if she was actually serious or not
avatar for bang69
bang69
5 years ago
Both
avatar for fenwayfav
fenwayfav
5 years ago
Romijn - no contest
avatar for busta_nut
busta_nut
5 years ago
love me some RR
avatar for DeclineToState
DeclineToState
5 years ago
Upton

Those pics of Romijn are great but she is declining and appears to have had a little cosmetic refreshing. Plus I’d like to cop a feel of dem Upton juggies
avatar for azdd
azdd
5 years ago
Kate Upton for me. Love the curves and have a tremendous woody-inducing fantasy of those eyes looking up at me while her lips are wrapped around my cock.
avatar for datinman
datinman
5 years ago
Close, but the fappening pics from a few years back tip it in favor of Upton.
avatar for georgmicrodong
georgmicrodong
5 years ago
No contest. Rebecca. I've seen naked pics of Upton, and Romijn dressed at her worst is still hotter than Upton naked at her best. Maybe not by much, but RR is definitely hotter for me.
avatar for TxVegas
TxVegas
5 years ago
Romijn
avatar for DrStab
DrStab
5 years ago
Kate
avatar for AnonymousJim
AnonymousJim
5 years ago
While the winning tally stayed largely on one side throughout, this was a good vote.

One reminder: Remember, we're evaluating the ladies in their prime. Someone pointed out Romijn may be slipping over time. Doesn't matter. We're voting on them at their best, not evaluating their longevity.

I'll add one vote for Upton to close it out.

UPTON: 20
ROMIJN: 14

̶I̶t̶'̶s̶ ̶g̶o̶o̶d̶ ̶t̶o̶ ̶b̶e̶ ̶b̶a̶c̶k̶:̶ ̶1̶
̶B̶o̶t̶h̶:̶ ̶1̶

Upton gets to dance/jiggle her way into the next round, though, as you'll see, she gets a tough challenge.

That's all for the second round in the Celebrity Bracket. Here's the matchups we'll have in the Sweet Pussy 16:

Donna D'ERRICO vs. Carmen ELECTRA
Salma HAYEK vs. Kate UPTON

These ought to be good.
You must be a member to leave a comment.Join Now