Who'd You Rather: Donna D'Errico vs. Dita Von Teese

avatar for AnonymousJim
AnonymousJim
Scanning the room from the back
First off, before we start, I knew these threads would eventually draw troll imitations. On TUSCL, anything done long enough gets trolled. Eh, we make use of the Ignore feature and press on.

I've been looking forward to this one, as it's going to test a theory I have. I'm fascinated to see how this will fall.

---

Celebrity Bracket: Donna D'ERRICO vs. Dita VON TEESE

---

Donna D'ERRICO

34C-22-34

PIC: https://www.tuscl.net/photo.php?id=1910
CLIP: (Playboy nude) https://www.vporn.com/vintage/donna-d-er…

---

Playboy and Baywatch by no means picked unattractive women to be their stars, but something about D'Errico seemed extra beautiful. Maybe it was her blonde hair, which always seemed to have great volume, her blue eyes beneath amazing lashes or her naturally pouty lips. Whatever it was, she caught your eye, even when surrounded by other beautiful women, and her willingness to go nude didn't hurt her appeal. That said, she is a little odd. She was married to Nikki Sixx of Motley Crue for 11 years, so she must not mind the rock lifestyle. Yet she is also deeply religious, going on a 2012 trip to Turkey with the crackpot premise of finding Noah's ark, during which, she suffered a major fall during a rockslide that nearly killed her. D'Errico was never a bigger star than she was on Baywatch and Baywatch Nights, and she made a point to do a photoshoot in a red swimsuit earlier this year to show she's still not bad looking for 51. Still, as amazing as her appearance was, it's surprising she was never more than a novelty star.

---

Dita VON TEESE

32DD-22-35

PIC: https://www.tuscl.net/photo.php?id=1937
CLIP: (burlesque striptease) https://www.pornhub.com/view_video.php?v…

---

You wouldn't think a woman raised in the northern part of Michigan's lower peninsula would eventually become the "Queen of Burlesque." Von Teese's road to hundreds of sold-out theater shows on worldwide tours started when she was disappointed the first bra she received from her mom wasn't as lacy as what she saw in her dad's Playboys. Now, she sells one of the world's most sought-after lingerie lines, turning the entrepreneurial spirit she developed as an Orange County club dancer (her family moved in her teens) into millions of dollars. That said, she did spend time married to Marilyn Manson for some reason, while her shows and brand have developed a campy atmosphere that appeals more to glam-obsessed women, gay men and drag queens than the average guy. Von Teese's brand is based on everything in her life being glamorous, even her cat, Aleister. As demanding as Von Teese is of herself and her look, she would surely be just as demanding of a man.

---

Let's throw 'em in the ring and see what happens.

D'ERRICO
VON TEESE
or NEITHER

27 comments

Jump to latest
avatar for rl27
rl27
5 years ago
Donna D'Errico
avatar for JAprufrock
JAprufrock
5 years ago
D'Errico in a massive blowout, or massive blowjob.
avatar for rh48hr
rh48hr
5 years ago
D'Errico

There's something about Von Teese that I like, but not enough to choose her over D'Errico.
avatar for Clubber
Clubber
5 years ago
Dita
avatar for pistola
pistola
5 years ago
Was going to say Dita but women worth $8m don’t need to give good head, so Donna.
avatar for PaulDrake
PaulDrake
5 years ago
D'ERRICO wins out barely for me over neither. Despite her being super gorgeous I am not into the 90s aesthetic.
avatar for IHearVoices
IHearVoices
5 years ago
Dita.
avatar for Call.Me.Ishmael
Call.Me.Ishmael
5 years ago
Dita
avatar for wallanon
wallanon
5 years ago
VON TEESE
avatar for bang69
bang69
5 years ago
Dita
avatar for jackslash
jackslash
5 years ago
Donna
avatar for chimera422
chimera422
5 years ago
Donna
avatar for TxVegas
TxVegas
5 years ago
Donna
avatar for seawa
seawa
5 years ago
Donna
avatar for prevert
prevert
5 years ago
Close one. Really close. Donna barely. Both are hot.
avatar for gSteph
gSteph
5 years ago
D'errico.

Tough call. Real close. Dita is hot, and I slightly prefer brunettes, but Donna's body looks very much like my favs, and I'm still buzzed from a recent visit with her.
avatar for datinman
datinman
5 years ago
Very close, but I'm going with Dita. Kind of like that Bettie Page vibe.
avatar for Muddy
Muddy
5 years ago
D’Errico and it’s not close
avatar for Ferdinx
Ferdinx
5 years ago
Donna
avatar for FishHawk
FishHawk
5 years ago
Dita
avatar for anthony6613
anthony6613
5 years ago
Dita
avatar for loper
loper
5 years ago
dita
avatar for Warrior15
Warrior15
5 years ago
Donna D'Errico is my perfect vision ! I don't think you could improve on that body one bit.
avatar for Longball300
Longball300
5 years ago
Dita just comes across as a nasty dirty girl who would be willing to do anything.

She gets my vote.
avatar for bullzeye
bullzeye
5 years ago
Donna
avatar for AnonymousJim
AnonymousJim
5 years ago
Time to close it off. I'll file a vote for D'Errico.

D'ERRICO 17
VON TEESE 10

̶A̶n̶ ̶u̶n̶c̶o̶m̶f̶o̶r̶t̶a̶b̶l̶e̶ ̶d̶i̶s̶c̶u̶s̶s̶i̶o̶n̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶r̶e̶g̶i̶o̶n̶a̶l̶ ̶g̶e̶n̶e̶t̶i̶c̶s̶:̶ ̶1̶

Donna D's C's best Dita's double-D's.

My theory was that Dita is more so a "woman's woman" than a "man's woman," as in moreso representative of what women want to think of as "being sexy" than actually being attractive to men, at least when you think about it.

I had a GF that was very into Dita's books and beauty tips. Yes, she has the Bettie Page thing going on, but I think @Longball is off base. Dita is obsessive about her look, her hair, her makeup, her skin, her fitness, her stage routines, etc., to the point of OCD at best and strict fussiness at worst. Consider whether you really want a woman who's that focused on herself. Honestly, I think @pistola's opinion might be more on-target than anything.

Granted, the 17-10 vote doesn't necessarily prove she's not attractive to you guys, and D'Errico is tough competition. But, she didn't win, and wasn't particularly close to winning, which also says something.

D'Errico will get the winner of a SI Swimsuit cover-model showdown between Rachel Hunter and Marisa Miller.
avatar for Assmanjoe
Assmanjoe
5 years ago
Im late but d’errico by a huge margin. Gould need a vida guerra type to go head to head with donna. OR eva mendes, thatd be a competition
You must be a member to leave a comment.Join Now