Which girl are you taking to VIP?

sexiness is a major consideration for me.

The “6”. Enthusiasm makes up a lot.

The 6. My grandmother used to cover the living room furniture with plastic, so it wouldn't get messed up. Sounds like the 9.

6

The 6, each time, every time. My favorite of late is certainly not my preferred body type (but definitely much better than a six) but her attitude and enthusiasm makes her a 10 in my book.

Man, my big head would say the 6 but my little one would say the 9. The problem is... 6 is pretty low.

Probably, I'd get dances with both and then repeat with whomever I had a better time with.

enthusiasm counts for a whole bunch.

Neither of them.
. The 9 sounds uptight and is likely to play games once in the VIP. And even if she delivers, it's likely to be a crap experience. . OTOH, a 6 is just lower than I'm willing to go if I'm handing over good money. I'd be regretting it the moment that post-nut clarity set in. I'd rather leave empty handed and save my ammo for a better option on another night.
. Sorry to be uncooperative with the spirit of this binary choice exercise, but to me the quality of the experience matters and neither of these girls fit the bill. I have enough fun over any given month with strong 7s, 8s and even the occasional 9 that I don't feel any urge to force the matter when what I want just isn't there.

@RD A fit 6 with great enthusiasm becomes a 7 or 8 when she's naked

The 6, especially if she is the “good body but just OK face” variety.

===> "A fit 6 with great enthusiasm becomes a 7 or 8 when she's naked" . I hear that. Maybe I'm just too spoiled now to settle on something I wouldn't naturally pick and that includes butterfaces. I'm finding enough attractive options now through different channels that if today is not the day, then tomorrow likely will be.

ITC is not my goal, but I'll settle for it if I have to on my way to something better. The 6 will be there. I'd take a look at the 9 in VIP to see what she's really about if properly motivated. The last time I passed up a 9 with perfect tits (it was at Club Risque in Philly) for VIP time I literally spent the rest of the Summer regretting it whenever I was back in town lol.

Neither.

I don't do extras. I'd take the 9 for a dance, and if nothing else enjoy the visuals and boob petting.

If the 6 had a 'pretty nice' body and a happy face (genuine smiles), I'd get some friction between our parts.

Fortunately my club almost always has 7-8s that split the difference in a satisfying way 🙂

Not enough info, so... it depends.

Not an extras hound, so maybe I just haven't "met the right one". But I've never had top-tier full service ITC. The type of fun I enjoy (different positions, laughs/giggles, some foreplay) can only be had OTC. So, assuming both the 9 and the 6 offer what I want but only ITC, I'm going for the 9. Of course, this also assumes the 6 is only facially a 6 and doesn't have some insane other (natural) assets I don't want to pass up.

Neither, I'm super picky when it comes to VIP, but I like to try em all out just for laps. That being said, if the 6 is super pretty face wise, I might be into it. I've had plenty of 9 mechanics, not worth it.

As long as the 9 is going to suck and fuck, the 9. I'm ugly, I'm creepy, and I appeal to women as much as genital warts. I get much more pleasure degrading a 9 than I do a 6. And having sex with me is going to be degrading.

I dont like doing it on a couch or ITC usually, although i havent been to any renowned ITC extras clubs so i dont know how things work.

I would avoid the 9… especially if youre looking to do the VIP on the same day. To me, the fact shes not taking her bottoms off in a full nude club is a sign that shes a scammer, and that she wont be open to any sort of extras other than a HJ or BJ. I dont think the 9 in this scenario is going to be willing to provide anything, so its basically a comparison of full service from the 6 vs mechanical lapdance from the 9.

Lex Luthor Ape said => “I'm ugly, I'm creepy, and I appeal to women as much as genital warts.”

Have you considered making a t-shirt and coffee mug with that catch phrase?

Interesting that most guys would go for the 6. I agree that she is a safer bet but I’d still be tempted to roll the dice on the 9 if we can agree on the VIP terms beforehand. Lots of 6s out there..

I’ll also be uncooperative with the binary exercise but take the other side of Dugan’s coin. I’ll do both. Likely not the same night but why not? Might there be regrets? Sure. Might there be a nice surprise? The fun is finding out. Wall knows all too well this has been my mongering for a few years now. Maybe not enough discipline but it’s led to some unexpected wow moments as well.

The six is going to make me finish, one way or another... She's got something to prove and she's building her list of regulars.

The 9 is a tough one, but definitely going to take more effort for similar (if ever) results.

My eyes want the 9. My dick wants the 6

the 9 hot pussy is hot pussy

Shadowcat might already have that T-shirt.

Most of you would have called my ATF a 6, but bar none save my wife, the absolutely best sex of my life.

There comes a time when a woman is "attractive enough", regardless of where she might fall on some scale. And to be fair, 6 is still better than average.

Can't say. There are too many other variables like cost and what else is available.

Exactly what godfather shadow said. Other variables. My guess would be that the 9 charges double.

Definitely taking the 6 if those are my only choices. But I am really hoping there is a friendly 7 hiding somewhere.

Asking for a tip for a mechanical dance without extras is a huge flag

Well, just strictly playing by this hypothetical scenario, I’d go with the 6. In reality, no dancer is likely to get my attention unless both looks AND personality hit fairly high marks. My ATF was a 10 in looks and a 10 in personality. My #2 ATF was a 10 in looks and a 9 in personality. I’m not looking for my future wife in a club, so the attraction factor better be pretty damn strong! :)

I agree that enthusiasm counts, but I'm not getting a dance from a 6 to find out if she's enthusiastic. At least not consciously, I've wound up with a few who I'd consider 6's in retrospect. But at the time I felt like they were at least 7's.

It's probably not the most wise approach, but if there weren't a few other 7-9's milling about I'd probably invest a little more time and money into trying to bring the 9 around into being a bit more friendly. I've pissed away a fair amount of good money with this approach, but my patience has also paid off enough in big enough ways to still make me take that bet. If I can't get a better feeling after some additional time, I cut bait and find another time or place to try throw my line back in.

In most cases though, I find a 7 or 8 and split the difference.

Neither. I dont do VIP and really dlnt engage in lap dances on most visits.

Are the rules that we can only take one of the dancers to VIP, for one VIP session?

In that case, there wont be any time to build rapport with the 9 in the hopes of getting more extras.
If its only one VIP with no prior VIPs for building rapport, i dont think the 9 would be open to much given “Maybe her bottoms never come off during the dances even though the club is full nude.”

6

I would always go for the “9”. If I can’t loosen her up, and have a good time in the VIP, then I’m losing my touch. Remember Pre-VIP work is essential….. if it ain’t happening ( you’re not clicking & laughing) during the discussion, it probably won’t happen in the VIP either. In that case, save your money and go with the “6”….lol