Will strip clubs reopen but have a shortage of strippers?

avatar for docsavage
docsavage
Indiana
Part of the stimulus bill includes an additional $600 per week in unemployment benefits for four months in addition to whatever state benefits exist. Normally there is a requirement that an unemployed person has to show they are actively looking for a job but an article in USA Today says this requirement is now being waived:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/202…

This means if the clubs are able to reopen in May or June the girls can keep getting their checks until the end of July. Many of them may decide to just stay home and take an extended vacation. This will be especially true of the strippers in the lower income ranges, though not so much for the club top earners. This may cause the clubs to be understaffed. Since many of the clubs will already be struggling with paying back rent and other expenses and trying to lure the customers back, an understaffed club may make it even more difficult for them to make money again. This may cause even more of them to go out of business. It may also make visiting strip clubs a frustrating experience for the customers with fewer girls at the club when we visit.

57 comments

Jump to latest
avatar for K
K
5 years ago
you assume they will be responsible with this money and not piss it away the day they get it.
avatar for docsavage
docsavage
5 years ago
"you assume they will be responsible with this money and not piss it away the day they get it."

They may piss away the $600 the moment they get it but they'll get another $600 the next week as long as they stay unemployed. There is an incentive here not to go back to work.
avatar for nicespice
nicespice
5 years ago
I’ll be back at the club when it opens, but I won’t be rushing to quit the day job when it happens.

Even clubs that 1099 dancers, I don’t think will show exact dates certain money was made. I’m sure plenty can and will double dip.
avatar for FishHawk
FishHawk
5 years ago
@k, do you think that us PL’s stuffing G-strings with $$ is not pissing it away. We PL’s and strippers both need each other.
avatar for CJKent (Banned)
CJKent (Banned)
5 years ago
NO
avatar for theDirkDiggler
theDirkDiggler
5 years ago
The only reason that the requirement to search for jobs is "generally" being waived is because the governments would rather have people to stay at home right now instead of "job hunting". Not to mention that very few places outside of Walmart, Amazon, grocers, fast food restaurants, deliverers of all types and those type of businesses are hiring anyway. Oh and cam sites which generally have to report their earnings to the governments where they earned money, how much they paid their "independent contractors".

As soon as the economy is "reopened", whatever that entails, and the government believes it's safe enough to resume searching for work or at the very least for certain businesses to reopen, you can bet the requirement to verify their job search will be back in place. Also, if the governments are smart (big if), they'll treat dancers as "furloughed workers" instead of "independent contractors". That is, when a company or business furlough ends, they take back their workers and the workers go back to work, unless the governments believe it's not safe enough to do so, in which case they'll remain closed. But if these places do reopen, then the government will assume that the "furlough" has ended and will be less likely to continue unemployment payments.

Now if this shutdown drags on past May and June, it won't make much of a difference, and by the end of July, once the bigger payments ends, the girls won't be able to keep paying their bills and will have to work anyway somewhere, unless another massive bailout takes place...
avatar for theDirkDiggler
theDirkDiggler
5 years ago
@nicespice
If the application for UI is the same for independent contractors as it is for employees or very similar, then the applicant has to state where they earned money the last calendar year. So even if the "1099" exists, and if it even is a requirement to get the UI benefits, and it doesn't state the time periods of when they earned money, the dancers themselves have to provide the exact times and places that they were "employed". They have to provide the "employer's" name and information as well and how much they "earned". Although right now, they're limited to only half of the average UI payment that the state gives, so it doesn't benefit them to report any more income than they have to.

So the UI office will have the last employer's information and typically before UI benefits are approved, they call that employer and ask them if a worker did work there and why they are no longer working there. So if they say that they did work there for whatever time periods the dancer claimed and they don't work there anymore because they were shut down because of the coronavirus, the dancer will likely be approved. This is the initial verification process. But when this business reopens, the UI people will generally find out about it as well. I don't think this system will be quite as easy to game.
avatar for docsavage
docsavage
5 years ago
"Also, if the governments are smart (big if), they'll treat dancers as furloughed workers instead of independent contractors. "

I hope you are right about this and your other comments are also right. The long term negative economic impact of this is going to be bad and may be made worse by poorly thought out plans to help people. If the government wisely does what you say they will, we will be ok here. I agree with those that say some short term government assistance is needed here.
avatar for JamesSD
JamesSD
5 years ago
I'm not sure how the $600 works, but with normal unemployment if you make say $40 for a one time gig you are supposed to report that and subtract it from your unemployment but can still collect the rest.

Strippers are in a cash business where they underreport earnings. Some are W2 employees, but the contractors may be able to scam the system and come back to work. I can tell you the one stripper whose life I was intimately involved with didn't report her earnings remotely close to accurate.
avatar for NJBalla
NJBalla
5 years ago
I think I said before but at least in NJ there is a huge summer lull. A lot of girls disappear for 2 months to go on lavish vacations. A lot of customers disappear at this time too. Family vacations, nice weather, and no major sports makes clubbing less enticing. I don't think a lot of guys will be in a rush to jump on a plane and live in a hotel with their families this summer. I think this summer will be very lucrative for dancers.
avatar for theDirkDiggler
theDirkDiggler
5 years ago
I don't know. The most recent information i saw with how they're treating these "gig" workers is that their state UI benefit will be half that state's average payment regardless of what they earned or report, which is more than fair considering they never paid into that system, and the difference between half the average and the full average is usually at most a couple hundred dollars, although in some states, dependents can make a bigger difference. Even if they get the full amount, the biggie is the $600. Also, a minimum income is usually required to qualify for UI benefits as well as a minimum amount of hours worked during a time period. Although with the coronavirus, these requirements might be relaxed somewhat, but not completely. A one time $40 gig in three months won't be enough to get the UI benefits plus the $600.

Some strippers are in a pure cash business and completely off the "books" at both the stripper and club level. I don't think these girls can get the benefits without both the stripper and the club being on the books. That is the stripper will have to admit that they evaded some taxes, and the club also failed to file a 1099. So many clubs (and strippers) might get audited, although i'm surprised many haven't been already. So i can see a lot of strippers not getting these benefits and relying on other things like onlyfans (what a joke) or OTC or SA/SB or even switching to cams although that is usually not off the books.
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
It will be really interesting to see what happens here. In CA, where the strippers are all employees anyway, their thinking may be different from where they are independent

What I do DEFINITELY expect is that all these girls will overwhelming SA. In fact, they are already doing so, but I think they're learning quickly that no one is meeting during this time, and very few of the men are interested in paying for pics or videos, so there's no real money to be made. Once the lockdown is lifted, though, I wonder if a stripper might think, "I'll collect my unemployment benefits, plus handpick one or three SDs for side money, and skate through the next year". Of course, that brings about its own issues -- it's likely SB allowances are going to fall a whole lot, and a zillion strippers joining will drive it even lower
avatar for goldmongerATL
goldmongerATL
5 years ago
If strippers are contractors (most places) tehy can show up to a club, make $$$ during a week and nothing will flag the UI machine to not send the the check. But remember that workers in "prurient" businesses are not eligible. They will have to fabricate some eligible Gig job. Do Gig workers have to somehow show proof they had a Gig job through tax returns.

If they are getting a W-2 and filing taxes from some job they should be OK.
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
5 years ago
@subraman what will be interesting is when these clubs reopen if the girls don’t return to work the clubs will go through that formal rehire which notifies the department of labor that a person was offered a job at which time UE benefits will be required to terminate by law.
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
Oh that's interesting! That's an added twist
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
5 years ago
^ could see a few of the smaller less scrupulous, strip club managers and owners charging these girls a premium on the house fees to not notify the Dept of Labor.
avatar for Mate27
Mate27
5 years ago
Probably, but I’m hesitant to return for a while after they reopen. I will not be a grasshopper.
avatar for Icey
Icey
5 years ago
They can make more than $600 a week. Its not an incentive to not work. You can't live off of that
avatar for Icey
Icey
5 years ago
Girls I know can't wait to get back to work
avatar for LinzeeDet
LinzeeDet
5 years ago
There will be a shit ton of girls and customers when things open back up. Mark my words. SHIT TON.
avatar for lotsoffun201
lotsoffun201
5 years ago
I agree with LinzeeDet. I just spoke to one of my dancer friends who agrees there will be a shit ton of girls once the clubs reopen. She also said probably girls who never danced before will be there as there old jobs are gone.
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
Linzee, the "shit ton of girls" is believable. It's the "shit ton of customers" that's a little harder... so many customers have been hit hard financially by this, and many others have lost their job. Plus customers tend to be older and I expect slower to come out. If the girls show up in droves, I'm not entirely sure the customers will
avatar for docsavage
docsavage
5 years ago
"They can make more than $600 a week. Its not an incentive to not work. You can't live off of that."

The $600 is just the additional amount the federal government is adding on top of state benefits, not the total amount. Average state benefits are around $280. As I mentioned in my original post above, the top earners are not going to be tempted by this. There are plenty of girls who only make between a hundred and two hundred a shift in many parts of the country. Getting close to $900 a week will tempt them to stay off, especially since there will still be a possibility of catching coronavirus for some time to come and a job where you come into close physical contact with a lot of strangers will be the type of job where you would get it. I would agree with theDirkDiggler above, though, that if and when the waiver ends and everyone is required to look for a job the former strippers will be back in the club. So will a lot of new girls who lost their old jobs. There will also be plenty of customers who lost their old jobs and they won't be there in the future.
avatar for rickdugan
rickdugan
5 years ago
===> "@subraman what will be interesting is when these clubs reopen if the girls don’t return to work the clubs will go through that formal rehire which notifies the department of labor that a person was offered a job at which time UE benefits will be required to terminate by law."

In CA I agree since dancers are treated as statutory employees. But in most parts of the country they are ICs who merely rent space, hence no tax or employment reporting of any kind.
avatar for rickdugan
rickdugan
5 years ago
To the question, sure i think that the unemployment money will impact the availability of dancers until it runs out. As everyone here knows, even ICs can collect it and they certainly have a case given that the government shut down their job sites. But it's not exactly a fortune, so I could see some dancers trying to supplement.
avatar for Muddy
Muddy
5 years ago
Hard to say. Different cities have different types of industries and economies. I do see more strippers on account of a lot of clubs going under. They gotta work somewhere. If you favorite club is still standing I see it having more yeah
avatar for Icey
Icey
5 years ago
Strippers would have had to file taxes to be eligible. Of course they'll under report their incomes. In some LA clubs where theyre employees they make as little as $57 a day. They wont have much more than the $600.

The real question is will there be rent and utility debt forgiveness and how fast will people have a disposable income again.
avatar for theDirkDiggler
theDirkDiggler
5 years ago
If they develop an accurate antibody test, that will go along way in if the dancers come back and especially customers. That is most of the customers will be ones that were already exposed to the coronavirus and recovered and hopefully immune so they can't get it again or give it to a vulnerable person. If a dancer has that status, the same for her. I just have no idea how many people will have that status. If it's only 10% of the country (which is still hundreds of thousands of deaths for the final total) then that's a huge reduction of the available pool of customers and possibly dancers. Also, if vast improvements in therapeutic treatment and care are found and developed, that may also have a positive effect...
avatar for Bamaeight
Bamaeight
5 years ago
I thinks most clubs will wave the rehire policy’s and forgive all past issues for former dancers also there will be new girls hitting the clubs to try and recover lost income from the shit downs and other places closing.
It will be the idea of fast easy money.

The clubs will be slow bringing business back in due to economic reason. Regular’s will be in with there girls and lots of open space between
avatar for Icey
Icey
5 years ago
I think dancers will have more choices. A lot of clubs screwed them over when they shut down. Some refuse to give them notices to prove theyre unemployed so they can get UI quicker. In Cali a lot got cheated on their pay. They won't forget those clubs.
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
5 years ago
@RickDugan in Florida the $875 is a lot of money, it’s not just the girls there are club employees that do need to make salaries not just ICs that will affect the operations of clubs, also the more steady customers are older and will not be so quick to return to the clubs, yes a small group of these are addicted in a sense, but the majority of folks with the kind of disposable income to make a difference in the club scene will take a while before they head back.
avatar for jackslash
jackslash
5 years ago
I agree that a lot of girls will show up when the clubs re-open. But I don't know about customers, especially older customers like me. I will want to know for certain that I won't catch a potentially fatal disease, and until that time I'm not going to the clubs.

I would be more open to OTC. One dancer coming to my home is less risky for me than going to a club with dozens of dancers and customers and staff, any one of whom could be carrying the virus.
avatar for gobstopper007
gobstopper007
5 years ago
I am hoping there’s a shit ton of strippers. I am fortunate in that I am not in high risk group and also have job classified as essential. I will be back as soon as work schedule allows.

I have continued putting in money in my sc slush fund. Hopefully I will be spending on familiar dancers, if not I will make some new friends. After so many weeks of shelter in place I am craving some high heels and thongs
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
Jack: I think you're right across the board, and said so myself earlier: I think the older customers who are the bread-and-butter for many strippers, are absolutely the slowest to come back. I'm not over 60 or 65 or wherever they've made the cutoff, and even I am thinking I'll be taking my time going back. After all, I have an SB (if I had an OTC girl, same thing) who I can see 1:1 while maintaining social distancing with everyone else. No reason for me to be rushing back to a strip club, unless/until one of those drugs under testing proves itself as a treatment. SA is awash in new girls (pretty sure many of them are strippers) so I can window shop strippers and pick and choose who I want to meet, even when I start jonesing for strippers again (which I definitely well... current SB is not a stripper/partygirl type, and I need one of those in my life lol)
avatar for Bmobrac
Bmobrac
5 years ago
Subraman, forgive my naïveté. What are SA and SB?
avatar for wallanon
wallanon
5 years ago
"All the furnishings should be replaced, the carpet (if any) pulled up, the curtains cleaned, etc. How many clubs are willing do do that?"

How frequently should that be done? A club I visit(ed) regularly replaced all of its carpet earlier this year and it took over a week to do. Viruses survive for a certain amount of time on surfaces. There are charts published online somewhere. Here is a summary in a recent Hopkins article.

https://hub.jhu.edu/2020/03/20/sars-cov-…

This information isn't perfect because science isn't perfect, and usually less accurate when done quickly on novel cases. But it's better than nothing.
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
"Subraman, forgive my naïveté. What are SA and SB?"

No worries. SA = Seeking Arrangement, a website to find sugarbabies... although it's full of strippers and escorts also. SB = sugarbaby.

The point for me being, at least until there's a medicine to address covid19, I'm more likely to stick with 1:1 interactions (with an SB, or OTC with a stripper with whom I have a pre-existing relationship) than go to the club
avatar for JamesSD
JamesSD
5 years ago
Linzee I think it honestly depends how the restrictions are lifted. If it's sort of a phase where some businesses are allowed to open but bars and clubs lag, then yes they will be packed the day they open. But if say all restrictions are lifted May 1 with a certain degree of voluntary social distancing expected, it may be more of a slow ramp up in the clubs.
avatar for JamesSD
JamesSD
5 years ago
Clubs really don't need to replace anything. Any club that has been closed for a week or more should be safe now. Dried jizz is more of a risk
avatar for nicespice
nicespice
5 years ago
I just looked it up, and around the club I’ll be going back to immediately after, construction is still going strong. So if there’s nothing else, I’m optimistic for the blue collar Mexican group at least. Less so for the oil guys. And the customer group tend to skew (for the most part) younger and in the 20s-40s. So likely a less cautious group. And even if they are cautious, quite a few customers at that club are already more into throwing singles for air dancing while clothed on the floor rather than going to the back anyways.

Fun club, that’s not really known for a being a serious money maker place. But I think will be okay enough when I return. Won’t be in a rush to quit the day job tho. Or travel in general for a while. 😢
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
I thihnk the wildcard here is treatment. Several of the mab class drugs hold promise, and hydroxychloroquine is still getting an anecdotal boost (still waiting on test results). I'd predict that as soon as there's an effective treatment, everyone without several comorbidities starts going out more and more. Although most people over 55 have at least one
avatar for nicespice
nicespice
5 years ago
Now as for some of these clubs that rely on constantly fresh foot traffic, especially with four figure champagne rooms, I wonder how those are going to change.

If # of girls end up being lowered, I feel like it will be more of a thing of the portion who went online are comfortable staying online more so than any unemployment thing. I could be wrong tho. And I’m not holding my breath and I’m sure there will be more than plenty of dancers.
avatar for datinman
datinman
5 years ago
I'm at the point in life where I have more money than time. It is very likely that I have already been exposed in my recent travels. When I get a positive antibody test confirming prior exposure, I plan on making up for lost time. Prince 1999 comes to mind.
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
Interesting news coming out of Wuhan: even as the city opens back up, there's a new warning for old people to continue social distancing, due to a concern about drastically increased cases of asymptomatic cases. In other words, old guys stay home -- lots of healthy young people can infect you, even after the "all clear", because there are far more asymptomatic cases than we thought.
avatar for PaulDrake
PaulDrake
5 years ago
I think the number of girls will go up not down. I have been seeing tons of posts from girls about how much they miss the club and can't wait to go back to dancing. A lot of girls just dance when they need money and they all need money now at the same time.
avatar for theDirkDiggler
theDirkDiggler
5 years ago
That makes no sense out of China. How could asymptomatic cases dramatically "increase"? So more than 90% of cases are asymptomatic now compared to 50%? That's been the data in Vo, Italy and the Diamond Princess where they tested everybody, or almost everybody with regards to the Diamond Princess (97%+ tested) and they found about half were asymptomatic, which is very striking on the cruise ship as most of the passengers (not crew) were older. So a lot of older people with this are asymptomatic as well. Also they're trying to test everyone in Iceland (already around 8% of the country has been tested) and from random testing they're getting around 50% asymptomatic. So with China, either cases there are just increasing dramatically in general and they're just lying about it; none of this no new cases that aren't imported BS...
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
5 years ago
@theDirk Asymptomatic cases increased because they have now tested many more folks, many of those getting tested now are through contact tracing, rather than because they appear to be or feel ill.
Not necessarily new cases, more likely just cases missed in the initial go round.
avatar for Subraman
Subraman
5 years ago
My guess is what 25 described -- the more we test, the more we learn. But still waiting for more confirmation.
avatar for wiffle shwaffle
wiffle shwaffle
5 years ago
There will most likely be even fewer customers than before with far more girls. Clubs were already oversaturated with dancers and all of the women who lost their jobs are going to need income. What's the easiest way to make money quickly? Dancing. I predict there will be a significant influx of new dancers, fewer customers than before, and even lower prices than before at extras clubs due to the increased competition amongst all of the new and veteran entertainers working.
avatar for BBBC
BBBC
5 years ago
^ I agree. I probably won't have to worry too much. My best two customers are both doing alright. RickDugan is still working and desertscrub seems to be doing well at shorting stocks. I am such a Lucky guy because they both can really suck a mean dick! They both love practicing on me also 😘
avatar for DandyDan
DandyDan
5 years ago
I don't know why anyone thinks there will be more dancers, especially the longer clubs are closed. Some who were dancing right up to the day they closed will no doubt end up dying from covid19. Some will probably decide on a new essential form of employment. Some will decide there won't be enough customers and decide not to dance. Plus who knows what kind of new restrictions they may put in place.
avatar for bman66
bman66
5 years ago
It will be interesting to see what happens in the Michigan clubs once they open back up. Hopefully they cleaned some of those VIP's.....Hope things bounce back to usual, time will tell!
avatar for Playademan
Playademan
5 years ago
Everyone is saying a lot of the strippers have gone to SA but they need to advertise better, been browsing and it’s hard to tell if someone was/is a dancer or not. I’d be much more inclined to initiate convo if I knew
avatar for JamesSD
JamesSD
5 years ago
Playa I bet you're the opposite of a lot of potential sugar daddies. Most dudes want to pretend she's a low mileage girl who is just open to dating an older guy who can help her out a little with her finances.
avatar for Hugh_G_Rection
Hugh_G_Rection
5 years ago
I'm looking in the crystal ball at future strip club reviews....
Oh, there's one where the OP said he had SIX girls dancing in July- Rosie Palm and her five sisters!!!!
avatar for max_starr
max_starr
5 years ago
I'm surprised it took until easter day to get a text from a house madam...I declined to respond to her...
i know whats up....OTC if I want it.
avatar for Slickwillie
Slickwillie
5 years ago
Limited, phased reopening of bars/nightclubs with 6ft separation and masks being discussed by govt and scientists. How is THAT going to work in a club?
You must be a member to leave a comment.Join Now