Mrs. Robinson vs her daughter: which one are you taking home?

56 comments

• FishHawk

  •

  5 years ago

  I go for Mrs. Robinson. She is still young for someone my age and probably more kinky.
• Uprightcitizen

  •

  5 years ago

  Hmmm....great question. I know Mrs. Robinson was definitely hard up with that dweeb of a husband. He was not getting the job done and she was ready to get...it...on. I need to watch this again to provide an accurate opinion.
• ATACdawg

  •

  5 years ago

  Elaine. She was a major hottie!
• pistola

  •

  5 years ago

  This depends, is this back in the era of the movie or now? In the era of the movie, Mrs Robinson. She’s experienced and has a checkbook and more likely to be open to some hot sex. Plus in that Era you could tell her make me a sammich and nobody would be offended. In today’s era, the daughter. The internet has taught women how to slobber and deep throat a cock at an early age and ride a D, the young gals are much more open sexually. Plus she is a millennial and thus living off mommy so she wouldn’t know how to make a sammich but she would be down to buy the avocado toast and Carmel frappucino on mommy’s credit card.
• GoVikings

  •

  5 years ago

  Nina...please read your PMs
• DrStab

  •

  5 years ago

  While Elaine was an attractive young lady, I would say that upon further review Anne Bancroft was the epitome of dirty little MILF. So bad and forbidden!
• RandomMember

  •

  5 years ago

  By coincidence I was listening to "April Come She Will" from the movie soundtrack earlier this evening. Classic movie and great soundtrack. I was thinking of seeing it again with current SB. Definitely hot Berkeley student, Elaine.
• Cashman1234

  •

  5 years ago

  Simon and Garfunkle didnt write a lyric about Elaine - it was all about Mrs Robinson - and so am I!
• nicespice

  •

  5 years ago

  Hmm, seems like this debate comes between a preference for the used up filthy whore (I know what Cashman will pick) vs the fresh faced girl-next-door (I know what PaulDrake will pick) Also, yay for this movie and yay for the Simon and Garfunkel song. 😁
• jackslash

  •

  5 years ago

  Mrs. Robinson. She was older than me when I saw the movie and now she's younger. How does that work?
• Uprightcitizen

  •

  5 years ago

  It's funny I had a serious crush on my Australian girlfriends mom in high school. My GF was hot but her mom could have had me anytime she wanted.
• doctorevil

  •

  5 years ago

  Both?
• PaulDrake

  •

  5 years ago

  Yeah definitely Elaine...
• NinaBambina

  •

  5 years ago

  I'm loving the answers. Keep them coming! My male friend chose Elaine simply because she's younger and "less traveled" as he put it. I chose Mrs. Robinson because she is sex-deprived and middle aged, so she would be eager to please in the bedroom, would probably try almost anything, and be down for several rounds. Elaine seems like she would be very boring in bed and lay on her back all the time. Plus you can find plenty of hot 21 year olds, but a hot woman in her 40s is much rarer (although Ann Bancroft was 35 during filming, for the sake of the discussion let's keep her middle-aged like her character). Carry on. 😊
• SirLapdancealot

  •

  5 years ago

  I'm going for the Mrs. She's better looking and more experienced. Closer to my age too. I'd fuck the shit out of her. She's Anne BANGcroft for crying out loud! A great movie in every way...screenplay, acting, cinematography, soundtrack.
• doctorevil

  •

  5 years ago

  Anne Bancroft was definitely a hottie. Hard to believe she was married to Mel Brooks,
• AnonymousJim

  •

  5 years ago

  My complements to everyone who has appreciated the soundtrack. Simon & Garfunkel found the height of their extensive genius with those songs. I mean, yeah, I'd probably lean toward Elaine. But Mrs. Robinson seemed a little crazy, controlling and vengeful, and the apple usually doesn't fall far from the tree. This feels like a bracket question. Gotta put these in alphabetical order, at least as far as we know: ELAINE Mrs. ROBINSON or NEITHER I choose NEITHER.
• anthony6613

  •

  5 years ago

  Mrs Robinson. I prefer milfs.
• AnonymousJim

  •

  5 years ago

  @heaving: To have the bracket early enough to include Anne Bancroft and Katharine Ross, we would have had to have done it on paper, via mail-in vote, in 1970-something. It almost tempts one to create a Onion-like newspaper-esque version of what TUSCL would have looked like in 1975. Topics: Do you prefer live bands behind or records during burlesque shows? What kind of tassles do you like? And @JAprufrock's avatar could still definitely be Bob Crane. Ross probably didn't hit her peak until later, like The Stepford Wives in 1975, while Bancroft hit hers much earlier, like The Restless Breed in 1957 (I had to do some Googling to figure this out, as I might recommend some of you do with your bracket votes). I see both having second or third round potential, but I think the Marilyn Monroes, Sofia Lorens and Racquel Welches of the time would knock them out. I just put way more thought into that than I should have. I want those last 10 minutes of my life back.
• twentyfive

  •

  5 years ago

  Hello darkness, my old friend I've come to talk with you again Because a vision softly creeping Left its seeds while I was sleeping And the vision that was planted in my brain Still remains
• AnonymousJim

  •

  5 years ago

  @heaving: [takes a bow] I'm here to please. As I tell my favorite dancers, I may not be tall, handsome or all that rich, but I like to think I know what I'm doing. @twentyfive: ... yeah. Mrs. Robinson. Sound of Silence. Even their version of Scarborough Fair. I may have been negative-15 when that album came out, but timeless is timeless.
• Muddy

  •

  5 years ago

  Mrs. Robinson nothing to do with age or maturity but just that actress was way hotter
• ATACdawg

  •

  5 years ago

  Plastics, my boy. Plastics!
• Clubber

  •

  5 years ago

  Daughter, for sure.
• JAprufrock

  •

  5 years ago

  Q: “Mrs. Robinson, shapely legs in black stockings.” A: “What is an image that still gets your dick hard 50 years later, Alex.”
• Longball300

  •

  5 years ago

  Mrs........ albeit a close call.
• twentyfive

  •

  5 years ago

  “Are you trying to seduce me Mrs Robinson” 😁
• Nidan111

  •

  5 years ago

  I’m all in when a hot 30 to 50 year old female is playing the field. I absolutely love experienced women. Since most every woman I have met is hot to me, experience takes precedence. I’m lucky in that my eyeballs see women as beautiful beyond belief. There is something fantastic to adore in most women.
• DeclineToState

  •

  5 years ago

  The Mrs.
• skibum609

  •

  5 years ago

  Anne bancroft was hot, experienced and wild. Elaine was attractive and vanilla/boring.
• loper

  •

  5 years ago

  Great discussion question! Both, of course, but Mrs. if only one. Of course, she might get crazy afterwards -- hard to deal with that.
• Huntsman

  •

  5 years ago

  Mrs. Robinson for me. Plenty hot in her own right and would be a wild fuck. With Elaine, I suspect that the highlight would be first seeing her naked and it would be downhill from there.
• shadowcat

  •

  5 years ago

  Watch "Rumor has it" and see if it changes your opinion. [view link]
• Electronman

  •

  5 years ago

  I would gladly accept the challenge of "educating" Elaine (Katherine Ross, who was also hot in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid). Someone has got to corrupt the cute, GND types.
• ATACdawg

  •

  5 years ago

  Note, too, that Mrs Robinson explicitly told Dustin Hoffman to stay away from her daughter. This implies that she knew she wouldn't stand a chance against Elaine in a "Who's the sexiest" throwdown. Yeah. I know. It's purely speculation on my part, but that's my story and I'm sticking to it!😜
• crazyjoe

  •

  5 years ago

  I never saw the movie, but one time I was in a club and got dances from a younger really hot dancer. As soon as I walked out of the dance area an older but cute dancer approached and had a million questions about how my dances went like, did she let you touch her boobs...etc. Then she said well, she must have liked you, now that you tried out my daughter, you better try the mom out because I am naughtier! Strange situation for sure.
• datinman

  •

  5 years ago

  Great thread! I hadn't thought of that movie in years. In the movie, I would rather have the character of Mrs. Robinson. In real life, I would have rather been with Katharine Ross. But mostly, I now want that red 66 Alfa Romeo Spider.
• SirLapdancealot

  •

  5 years ago

  "Note, too, that Mrs Robinson explicitly told Dustin Hoffman to stay away from her daughter. This implies that she knew she wouldn't stand a chance against Elaine in a "Who's the sexiest" throwdown." ^ @ATACdawg no disrespect but I disagree. It could easily imply that since Dustin was easy enough to just sleep with her, then he wasn't the right type for her daughter. She's just being a good mother while at the same time being a sex slut for Dustin. Plus she's hotter and sexier than her daughter in all ways.
• ATACdawg

  •

  5 years ago

  That's certainly a potentially valid explanation. However, it's my fantasy and I'm sticking to my version!😃
• NinaBambina

  •

  5 years ago

  I don't want to get too OT from the thread, but I agree with SirLapdancealot. No decent mom would want her daughter with someone like Ben, who has been inside of her.
• NinaBambina

  •

  5 years ago

  Whereas you have to take into account some younger guys like older milf types, so some of Elaine's boyfriends would secretly want to fuck her, anyway. It's not like Elaine would be the universal preference, as we can see from the guys that have voted for Mrs Robinson.
• SirLapdancealot

  •

  5 years ago

  @NinaBambina did you have a bet riding on this or something?
• NinaBambina

  •

  5 years ago

  Lol no, I was just curious about what the general consensus would be and I figured this would be a good group to ask. I was also high so it seemed like a fun thread to start.
• Cashman1234

  •

  5 years ago

  Sadly nobody suggested Mrs Robinson and Elaine exploring each other. Maybe then inviting you to slowly penetrate Elaine - as Mrs Robinson looks deeply into your eyes - and spreads her legs to rub her pussy while evaluating your sexual prowess and deciding whether she will let you inside of her while your cock is still moist with her daughter’s juice....
• NinaBambina

  •

  5 years ago

  ^Aw, fanfic.
• Cashman1234

  •

  5 years ago

  There must be a porn version of the Graduate. Obviously my post is just a fantasy.
• SirLapdancealot

  •

  5 years ago

  LMAO Cashman wrote that shit as if it's part of go-to spank bank stock. It's like he watched the Graduate numerous times alone with a bottle of baby oil and he was reliving the moment.
• Cashman1234

  •

  5 years ago

  SirLDAlot - that’s funny! It’s also wrong. I watched it with a bottle of lotion - not baby oil! Lol!
• DennisKe

  •

  4 years ago

  Elaine. I married Mrs. Robinson. Great sex but (surprise!) serial cheater.
• Call.Me.Ishmael

  •

  4 years ago

  I'm almost exclusively happy about this thread being bumped because ... you know ... Nina's boobs.
• Hank Moody

  •

  4 years ago

  I agree Ish. I miss Nina’s boobs.
• BocaOnt2019

  •

  4 years ago

  Apologies if this was already mentioned but the actress who played Mrs. Robinson (Anne Bancroft) was only 36-37 at the time of filming.
• mark94

  •

  4 years ago

  Anne Bancroft was 35 and Katherine Ross was 26 at time of filming. I’d choose Ross every day of the week and twice on Sunday.
• Jascoi

  •

  4 years ago

  how about a threesome?
• Jascoi

  •

  4 years ago

  oh... cashman allready said that.
• woodstock

  •

  4 years ago

  I'd go for Maude.