The Pony Indy

Indianapolis, Indiana

The Pony Indy Reviews

• review

  a month ago
  I want more

  Im back after my long but eventful hiatus. As a midwester I’m usually around the Chicago, Indy, Detroit area so this week I was Indy and decided to roll the dice and hunt. The...
  Mr Monger
• review

  5 months ago
  Not Bad, But Not My Thing

  A recent Saturday night found me at The Pony for the first time in well over a year. I've been skipping the club partly because it's inconveniently-located for me and partly because my previous...
  Comments: 2

  last:

  5 months ago

  by

  Tiredtraveler
  MasterT71

  Indiana
• review

  a year ago
  recommended

  I arrived late on a recent Monday night. 10-12 cars in the lot. $10 cover charge. Kind of dumb to charge cover on a slow Monday but I get it. Main guy collecting cover...
  Comments: 2

  last:

  9 months ago

  by

  docsavage
  captainfun

  new city, new club
• review

  a year ago
  one of the better options in the area

  This club is in Indianapolis which is different from how it is displayed on this site. I was at the club several weeks ago on a Wednesday night. Surprised to see that the last...
  Comments: 3

  last:

  a year ago

  by

  racejeff
  captainfun

  new city, new club
• review

  2 years ago
  good club

  I had been to this club just one other time around 9 pm on a weekday 4-5 years ago. Had an opportunity to be in Indianapolis last Saturday and was at the club from...
  captainfun

  new city, new club
• review

  2 years ago
  Hey God Dammit, stop trying to hump the pony! How many times do we gotta say it?

  Indianapolis, IN. Tuesday night. Originally wanted to go to Dancers but said fuck that their parking lot was so dead, I knew it'd be a waste. I came here instead on my way through...
  Muddy

  USA
• review

  2 years ago
  Not great, but not bad; felt like it had potential to be better a different night

  The Pony was about a fifteen minute drive from downtown. It had a large, free parking lot that wrapped around the back of the club. The nearer side parking was mostly full whenI arrived,...
  schmoe31415

  Whatever
• review

  2 years ago
  High inflation hits the Indianapolis club scene

  I arrived at this club around ten on a Friday night. It was $10 to get in and paid another five for a bottled water. I sat up at the bar and waited for...
  Comments: 2

  last:

  2 years ago

  by

  boredinsb
  docsavage

  Indiana
• review

  3 years ago
  Neither rain, nor sleet, nor snow....

  I visited the pony for the first time last Friday at 8:30p. Normally it opens its doors at 3p but it apparently opened at 6 or 7 due to the weather. $10 cover at...
  Comments: 1

  last:

  3 years ago

  by

  docsavage
  Chance073
• review

  3 years ago
  Good Club, Unsecure Parking Lot

  In summary The Pony is a fun club, with something for everyone. Lots of plusses and only a few minuses. Features full spectrum of dancer types, fair prices and a variety of seating options....
  Comments: 3

  last:

  3 years ago

  by

  HungryGiraffe
  HungryGiraffe

  Somewhere USA
• review

  3 years ago
  On Sundays the Ponies are in the Stable, Not to Play.

  I'm currently sitting in the club with 5 other guys. Definitely comes off as a higher end club at first with the bottles in closed cases as you walk into the main area. DJ...
  Comments: 1

  last:

  3 years ago

  by

  docsavage
  Fratboy908

  Detroit, MI
• review

  4 years ago
  The Return of the Pony

  The Pony was reopened when I stopped by tonight. This club has been there for years but has gone through various ownership changes. It was formerly known as Rick's Cabaret and before that Brad's...
  docsavage

  Indiana
• review

  5 years ago
  Very Hit or Miss Place (mostly miss, but this was a good night)

  This place, under multiple names, and even more owners, has been a go-to for me for 15 years. It's convenient, and for a long time was consistently great. Not so much now, though tonight...
  tdn77

  Indiana
• review

  5 years ago
  Underrated club

  I would not consider this a great club but I would consider it to be the most underrated club in Indianapolis. Indicative of that is the long time period between this review and...
  docsavage

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  Not what I expected

  I went in with the expectation of being able to get some extras because last time one of the dancers claimed she does them. So I get for 10 dollars not bad. The policy...
  Bobdong

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  Dead at 8pm

  Went here around 8pm on a Tuesday. Place was dead. Thankfully they had some decent beers on tap for a good price. Asked the bartender what was up with the lack of action and...
  BigDiesel

  Illinois
• review

  6 years ago
  Miracle at the Pony

  In the past I've had some issues with this club, not so much with the strippers but with the customers. It's in a bad part of town and attracts a little too much of...
  Comments: 1

  last:

  6 years ago

  by

  racejeff
  docsavage

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  Same Good Experience, same late night club.

  Arrive just before 8 pm, they were taking $10 cover and putting wristband on you. Cover seems a little high but cover to me is a minor thing given the total will spend...
  racejeff

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  An club trying to be upscale

  The parking is lite OK but most is on the side and back. Judging from the crowd most of the parking in front is consumed by employees. A bouncer outside asked for ID and patted...
  Tiredtraveler

  Solo PL
• review

  6 years ago
  Hidden gem

  Driving up to the pony you’d think it’s the sketchiest SC ever. I arrived a little before 10 pm that night there weren’t a lot of dancers yet just a couple were there. None...
  Bobdong

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  Great Under The Radar Club but watch time of visit.

  Arrived after 7 PM a week ago Friday and the parking lot was pretty empty. while the guy was checking my ID he responded "The girls don't have to be here until 10." ...
  Comments: 2

  last:

  6 years ago

  by

  racejeff
  racejeff

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  Good club

  I used to go to this club back when it was Rick's. The layout is pretty much the same. However the interior was remodeled and looks good. I got to the club about 8...
  Comments: 1

  last:

  6 years ago

  by

  racejeff
  iabnysmwytm

  Indiana
• review

  6 years ago
  A tale of Four Trips

  It's been a while since I've been here for a regular night so I'm adding in some special event visits. First the regular visit last night. I entered at 7:30 a little early than...
  Comments: 2

  last:

  6 years ago

  by

  racejeff
  racejeff

  Indiana
• review

  7 years ago
  Another enjoyable visit

  This is actually a combination of past 2 Friday nights. Arriving at 8 to 8:30 The cover has been $10 but this week was only $8. I drink non alcohol stuff mostly prices...
  racejeff

  Indiana
• review

  7 years ago
  Never Any Action

  Every time I have been in this place it is a ghost town. Everyone sits around the bar. No dancers on stage. Bartender usually is the hottest girl in there. ...
  Comments: 1

  last:

  7 years ago

  by

  joefriday
  Longdong454545

  Indiana