The Pony Indy
3551 Lafayette Rd Indianapolis, IN 46222

Hey God Dammit, stop trying to hump the pony! How many times do we gotta say it?

VIP Review
Avatar for Muddy
VIP
Muddy
Aug 20, 2022, 1:42 AM
Dancers
Club Quality
Value
Visited: Tuesday Evening

Indianapolis, IN. Tuesday night. Originally wanted to go to Dancers but said fuck that their parking lot was so dead, I knew it'd be a waste. I came here instead on my way through Indy. On a main thoroughfare on Lafayette road. A big pony statue right out front. Plenty of parking. Walk in, really big white dude maybe like 6'7 checks ID. Cover was $10. Free military. Customers mostly older white dudes it looked like and a couple black older black dudes. My beer was cheap only $3 or $4. Lap dances are $25 in a community dance room, well lit not to much privacy from others getting dances in there, open door. Layout oval bar, dance room next to that, stage and seating off on right. One dancer at a time. Bathroom between bar and stage.

Lineup. I've always heard BBF and Dancers were the top options in town and those are the only ones I've been to so far but you know what, I wouldn't sleep on this lineup. Definitley quality. No 9's and 10's but I didn't see anyone who shouldn't be dancing. All younger girls. All slimmer side for the most part. 50/50 white and black girls maybe I think a latina in there. I overheard one dancer saying that maybe BBF was more popular but as far as working there she prefers here. About 15 girls when I came. Ultimately I can't say I saw anything for me, but this lineup is solid here. I got in around 9 as it started filling up dancer wise and it looked like the dance room was pretty open so maybe that's a better time. You don't really hear about this spot as much but maybe I'd pop my head in to see if there was something you were into.

Full review available to VIP members

Unlock thousands of detailed, honest strip club reviews.

300K+ reviews • Trusted community since 1998