Voting Yes to a bad review

There is currently a PoleKatz review from a dancer on the unpublished list that has no specifics about the club, it is just a rant about how cheap the customers are. I should have copy/pasted to this thread, but didn't think of that until I had already voted.

My question is: Is there any value to posting a bad review if it is likely to open a dialogue in the comments section?

I kind of enjoyed the comments given to prior posts that under the current system might not see the light of day.