Who would you choose?

I choose my ex wife.

Just kidding.

Id choose the DS

Wow, tough question. It's a coin flip between my ex gf, my current SB, and my ex fav stripper. Since I've had sex countless times with my ex gf, I'll rule her out. Between my SB and ex fav, it's a tie I think. I've only had sex with my ex fav ITC and never OTC, so I'll have to give her the nod. OTC with my ex fav would be my first choice by just a hair. I'd say by a pussy hair, but she's bare down there. :)

I didn't even have to think.

I met a girl when I was 17 and on vacation in Florida with my family. Years later we linked up when I was 22 and had a long distance relationship that lasted less than a year. Man she was smoking hot, petite, dark brown (almost black) hair and sparkling blue eyes, with pale skin. I seriously wanted to marry this girl but I couldn't because she couldn't even count to 10 and she was horrible in bed. She thought sex was a race, see how fast you can cum and then it's over. Even though we were the same age we were in different places in our life. Me just graduating college, her not attending college and going nowhere in life.

Thanks to Facebook I find her a decade later, fat, now bottle blonde with 2 kids and married to what has to be one of the ugliest son of a bitches I have ever seen ugh! Guess that was a good bullet to dodge.

I would take the younger her, lets just say at 20 years old for fun. I'd tie her up this time around and take my time.

Penny from Sky King or Weena from The Time Machine.

Britney Spears has always intrigued me. I recently watched a clip of her exercising/ dancing and she's got a great body and apparently stamina to spare.

I just re-read the post & you specified from my sexual past - that leaves out Britney. I had a HS GF who was a little heavier than I like today but she had generous breasts which I'd motorboat, suck on and fondle for hours. She had a slim waist and I never got below it. Her family moved to Wiscosin during her junior year of HS and we stayed in touch. Two years later I drove out to visit and slept on the family's living room couch. During the night she crept downstairs, touched her finger to my lips to silence me as I looked St her sheer peignor which was backlit, indicating clearly nothing beneath it. We kissed and she quickly bent over taking my raging hard-on into her mouth and I splooged 18 years of cum directly into her mouth, gagging her, staining the couch and my pajamas. As she pulled away I shot another spurt which hit a linen lampshade and her face. Just then her father called down the stairs for her to get to bed.
I never did fuck her. She went on to win the Miss Teenage Wisconsin title and given the opportunity I'd like to have her 17 year old body as a playmate today.

tatum before her tats. baby before her attitude.kendra before her boob job. bbfs 69.

Hard decision because I really like my ATF that I am seeing but there was this Russian escort years ago that probably would win the prize of a bbfs session just because she was insanely hot...a true 10.

Great story, Gawker!

My ex g/f Brenda. Had she not wanted 5 kids I'd have married her, but since I wanted none we were done after 5 years. The single most beautiful woman I have seen in my life. I still have a pic of the two of us from 1982 and every time I look at it I realize I had forgotten she was a true 10.

I'd fuck someone new. I'm not interested in any of my past sexual partners.

theses ladies from the wwe
1. the bella twins
2. sasha banks
3. page
4. lana
5. bwcky lynch

My wife.

I'd Fuck the ds again too.

Just kidding. Fuck that bitch.

Ex-girlfriend who, at the time was smoking hot and a sexual maniac. She always talked about the two of us having sex with two other girls "even if we have to hire them". Circumstance never presented itself and we never followed through with the professional help. Being pretty young at the time I was somewhat hesitant about the whole thing...... now I say "damn, what the hell was I thinking".

The ATF. Other contenders would be HS crush who was into me too, but I was too chicken shit to pull it off. Next was the HS slut who gave me my first boner and later on found out was a stripper.

Yeah why limit it to someone from your past. Been there...done that.