Hot Summer in Rhode Island
Dudester
http://www.projo.com/news/content/teen_d…
Minors in R.I. can be strippers
11:44 AM EDT on Tuesday, July 21, 2009
By Amanda Milkovits
Journal Staff Writer
PROVIDENCE –– Rhode Island teens under 18 can't work with power saws or bang nails up on roofs.
Related links
Lt. Gov. Roberts wants law to ban underage strippers
Your turn: Do you think 16 and 17 is too young to be a stripper?
Read Title 11 Criminal Offenses, Chapter 11-9 Children, Section 11-9-1 of Rhode Island Law
Extra: Behind closed doors: How R.I. decriminalized prostitution
But dance at strip clubs? Sure. Just as long as the teens submit work permits, and are off the stripper's pole by 11:30 on school nights.
It's enough to surprise even those in America's mecca of striptease and sin –– Las Vegas.
“Everybody buzzes about ‘Nevada and Sin City, tsk, tsk,' †said Edie Cartwright, spokeswoman for the Nevada attorney general's office. “But we regulate it.â€
Providence police recently discovered that teen job opportunities extend into the local adult entertainment world while they were investigating a 16-year-old runaway from Boston. The girl told detectives that she worked at Cheaters strip club this spring, and the police got tips about other underage girls working at another club on Allens Avenue.
That's when the police found that neither state law, nor city ordinance bars minors from working at strip clubs. Those under 18 can't buy pornography, and no one may take pictures or film minors in sexually suggestive ways. But the law doesn't stop underage teens from stripping for money. Even if the police saw underage boys or girls on stage at a strip club, they wouldn't be able to charge them or the club owners with a crime.
“I've been doing this a long time,†said youth services Sgt. Carl Weston, “and I can't find anything that says it's illegal for a 16-year-old or a 17-year-old to take her top off and dance.â€
State law says that anyone who employs a person under 18 for prostitution or for “any other lewd or indecent act†faces up to 20 years in prison and up to $20,000 in fines. But that isn't enough to prevent underage girls from working in strip clubs, said senior assistant city solicitor Kevin McHugh, who researched the issue a dozen years ago when a teenage dancer was found at a raided strip club.
The term “lewd or indecent†is subjective, McHugh said, and is applied to behavior that's protected by the First Amendment. “Since we have strip clubs in Providence,†McHugh said, “citizens don't consider [stripping] lewd.â€
With the age of consent at 16 in Rhode Island, the police worry that teenage strippers could take their business to the next level and offer sexual favors –– and it wouldn't be illegal. State law currently allows indoor prostitution, and two bills intended to ban it have stalled in the General Assembly.
State and federal child labor laws dictate the number of hours and times of days that minors may work, and forbid certain jobs considered to be hazardous. For example, those under 16 can't work on ladders or pump gas. Youths age 16 and 17 can't work in manufacturing or excavation.
“Nowhere does it say anything about a kid not being able to strip,†Weston said.
Establishments with city liquor licenses need to keep the teenagers from the booze, but not the stage. “You can't serve alcohol if you're under 18,†Weston said, “but you can be the target of a man's groping hands at age 16.â€
But a Rhode Island teen stripper won't find work in Massachusetts, where state law prohibits anyone from hiring minors under 18 for live performances involving sexual conduct.
Other states have had mixed encounters with the issue.
After a 12-year-old girl was found dancing nude in a club in Dallas last year, the city council swiftly passed rules barring minors from strip clubs and automatically revokes for a year licenses for sex businesses caught employing or entertaining minors.
But an Iowa county judge ruled last year that a striptease by a 17-year-old girl at a strip club was artistic expression protected by the First Amendment. The state attorney general's office has asked the state Supreme Court to review the ruling.
Nevada, meanwhile, doesn't let anyone under 18 work in casinos or in public dance halls where there is alcohol — and there are no strip clubs in Nevada without one or the other, or both, said Cartwright, of the attorney general's office. Minors aren't even allowed to deliver mail to brothels.
When questioned about Rhode Island's law, Michael J. Healey, a spokesman for the attorney general's office, offered a copy of the current state law but did not comment for this article.
But Weston, of the Providence police, was adamant that the law should be changed.
“It leads to a societal breakdown,†he said. “These are just little girls.â€
Minors in R.I. can be strippers
11:44 AM EDT on Tuesday, July 21, 2009
By Amanda Milkovits
Journal Staff Writer
PROVIDENCE –– Rhode Island teens under 18 can't work with power saws or bang nails up on roofs.
Related links
Lt. Gov. Roberts wants law to ban underage strippers
Your turn: Do you think 16 and 17 is too young to be a stripper?
Read Title 11 Criminal Offenses, Chapter 11-9 Children, Section 11-9-1 of Rhode Island Law
Extra: Behind closed doors: How R.I. decriminalized prostitution
But dance at strip clubs? Sure. Just as long as the teens submit work permits, and are off the stripper's pole by 11:30 on school nights.
It's enough to surprise even those in America's mecca of striptease and sin –– Las Vegas.
“Everybody buzzes about ‘Nevada and Sin City, tsk, tsk,' †said Edie Cartwright, spokeswoman for the Nevada attorney general's office. “But we regulate it.â€
Providence police recently discovered that teen job opportunities extend into the local adult entertainment world while they were investigating a 16-year-old runaway from Boston. The girl told detectives that she worked at Cheaters strip club this spring, and the police got tips about other underage girls working at another club on Allens Avenue.
That's when the police found that neither state law, nor city ordinance bars minors from working at strip clubs. Those under 18 can't buy pornography, and no one may take pictures or film minors in sexually suggestive ways. But the law doesn't stop underage teens from stripping for money. Even if the police saw underage boys or girls on stage at a strip club, they wouldn't be able to charge them or the club owners with a crime.
“I've been doing this a long time,†said youth services Sgt. Carl Weston, “and I can't find anything that says it's illegal for a 16-year-old or a 17-year-old to take her top off and dance.â€
State law says that anyone who employs a person under 18 for prostitution or for “any other lewd or indecent act†faces up to 20 years in prison and up to $20,000 in fines. But that isn't enough to prevent underage girls from working in strip clubs, said senior assistant city solicitor Kevin McHugh, who researched the issue a dozen years ago when a teenage dancer was found at a raided strip club.
The term “lewd or indecent†is subjective, McHugh said, and is applied to behavior that's protected by the First Amendment. “Since we have strip clubs in Providence,†McHugh said, “citizens don't consider [stripping] lewd.â€
With the age of consent at 16 in Rhode Island, the police worry that teenage strippers could take their business to the next level and offer sexual favors –– and it wouldn't be illegal. State law currently allows indoor prostitution, and two bills intended to ban it have stalled in the General Assembly.
State and federal child labor laws dictate the number of hours and times of days that minors may work, and forbid certain jobs considered to be hazardous. For example, those under 16 can't work on ladders or pump gas. Youths age 16 and 17 can't work in manufacturing or excavation.
“Nowhere does it say anything about a kid not being able to strip,†Weston said.
Establishments with city liquor licenses need to keep the teenagers from the booze, but not the stage. “You can't serve alcohol if you're under 18,†Weston said, “but you can be the target of a man's groping hands at age 16.â€
But a Rhode Island teen stripper won't find work in Massachusetts, where state law prohibits anyone from hiring minors under 18 for live performances involving sexual conduct.
Other states have had mixed encounters with the issue.
After a 12-year-old girl was found dancing nude in a club in Dallas last year, the city council swiftly passed rules barring minors from strip clubs and automatically revokes for a year licenses for sex businesses caught employing or entertaining minors.
But an Iowa county judge ruled last year that a striptease by a 17-year-old girl at a strip club was artistic expression protected by the First Amendment. The state attorney general's office has asked the state Supreme Court to review the ruling.
Nevada, meanwhile, doesn't let anyone under 18 work in casinos or in public dance halls where there is alcohol — and there are no strip clubs in Nevada without one or the other, or both, said Cartwright, of the attorney general's office. Minors aren't even allowed to deliver mail to brothels.
When questioned about Rhode Island's law, Michael J. Healey, a spokesman for the attorney general's office, offered a copy of the current state law but did not comment for this article.
But Weston, of the Providence police, was adamant that the law should be changed.
“It leads to a societal breakdown,†he said. “These are just little girls.â€
9 comments
Comment: the Dallas club certainly did not "allow" a known 12-year-old to dance nude. If I remember this case correctly, she looked and behaved much older than her chronological age, and had definitely lied about her age. She had had "personal experiences at home" before ever entering a strip club that had, I believe, given her some pretty explicit, appropriate, training for the job. And also, if I recall, she was a runaway.
But whatever the truth in that case, there is a big difference between a chronological age of 12 and 16. As long as a sixteen-year-old girl knows what she is doing, and is not under coercion of any kind, I don't see what the problem is. (Let the market rule.) Soon she won't be 16 any more, and then she won't be 17 any more, and .... well you get the idea.
http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2009…
They cover both the underage strippers and indoor prostitution laws (or lack there of) in R.I.
http://newsblog.projo.com/2009/07/mayor-…
This will cover the vast majority of the strip clubs in RI, but I don't think that it will really affect anything until those clubs start coming up for license renewals.