Could someone please explain to me why providing photo ID to vote is racist
Muddy
USA
Now we're moving to get the MLB All star game out of Atlanta over this? Is that what we're seriously doing? I'm all ears just explain to me why that this is about race. I'm willing to change sides I just completely don't get it. To me if your unable to simply produce photo identification, if we can't simply get past that very, very simple obstacle then maybe we shouldn't be having a say in country's direction. Baby steps here. Call me crazy.
Got something to say?
Start your own discussion
86 comments
Latest
The ID thing makes sense. That doesn’t seem racist. I understand they want to make voting as simple as possible. When voting by mail - it’s important to read the instructions. When voting in person - it’s important to read the instructions too. Providing your ID protects the voter.
If folks waiting in line are swayed by someone offering them a drink or a sandwich - they don’t have strongly held beliefs in the first place. I see no issue with allowing the voters to be offered food.
If they offer chacken fangers and a side of BBQ - Juice might be first in line!
“A terrible and bloody Civil War freed enslaved Americans.
The Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution (1868) granted African Americans the rights of citizenship.
However, this did not always translate into the ability to vote.
Black voters were systematically turned away from state polling places.
To combat this problem, Congress passed the Fifteenth Amendment in 1870. It says:
The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.
Yet states still found ways to circumvent the Constitution and prevent blacks from voting.
Poll taxes, literacy tests, fraud and intimidation all turned African Americans away from the polls.
Until the Supreme Court struck it down in 1915, many states used the "grandfather clause " to keep descendents of slaves out of elections.
The clause said you could not vote unless your grandfather had voted -- an impossibility for most people whose ancestors were slaves.
This unfair treatment was debated on the street, in the Congress and in the press.
A full fifty years after the Fifteenth Amendment passed, black Americans still found it difficult to vote, especially in the South.
“What a Colored Man Should Do to Vote", lists many of the barriers African American voters faced.
The fight for African American suffrage raged on for decades. In the 1930s one Georgia man described the situation this way:
"Do you know I've never voted in my life, never been able to exercise my right as a citizen because of the poll tax? ... I can't pay a poll tax, can't have a voice in my own government."
Many brave and impassioned Americans protested, marched, were arrested and even died working toward voting equality.
In 1963 and 1964, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. brought hundreds of black people to the courthouse in Selma, Alabama to register.
When they were turned away, Dr. King organized and led protests that finally turned the tide of American political opinion.
In 1964 the Twenty-fourth Amendment prohibited the use of poll taxes.
In 1965, the Voting Rights Act directed the Attorney General to enforce the right to vote for African Americans.
The 1965 Voting Rights Act created a significant change in the status of African Americans throughout the South.
The Voting Rights Act prohibited the states from using literacy tests and other methods of excluding African Americans from voting.
Prior to this, only an estimated twenty-three percent of voting-age blacks were registered nationally, but by 1969 the number had jumped to sixty-one percent.
Today, and in the near future, getting a photo ID so you can vote is easy. Unless you’re poor, black, Latino or elderly.
“Many Americans do not have one of the forms of identification states acceptable for voting.
These voters are disproportionately low-income, racial and ethnic minorities, the elderly, and people with disabilities.
Such voters more frequently have difficulty obtaining ID, because they cannot afford or cannot obtain the underlying documents that are a prerequisite to obtaining government-issued photo ID card."
The costs associated for voters seeking a photo ID is again a “poll tax,” a return to fees that some Southern states used to disenfranchise blacks during the Jim Crow era of laws enforcing racial segregation between the late 1800s through 1965.
Only British are more racist than Americans, because the British father the Americans.
You are welcome.
These people cannot buy guns, they cannot hold many jobs, they cannot fly, etc... My guess is that if they wanted a govt photo id they could get one, this is just political posturing by both sides
Today, here and now, and in the near future, in America getting a photo ID so you can vote is easy. Unless you’re poor, black, Latino or elderly.
At least 20% of the people in America falls in a combination of black, brown and poor, uneducated.
~ jackslash
~ older strip club customer, dancers often tell him he resemble a movie star. The movie star is Woody Allen.
13 Minutes Ago
“Laws to limit the black vote may not seem racist on the surface but may be racist in practice.”
~ jackslash
~ older strip club customer, dancers often tell him he resemble a movie star. The movie star is Woody Allen.
The really wild thing about the ID is not only how permissive things are with voting, but practically encouraged. It was actively being encouraged to non-Colorado residents to vote in Colorado the last election. You didn’t even need to provide address when registering. And several individuals I know did just that. I’m all against elitism but I thought that was a bit far lol.
It would be hilarious if during the next election, encourage a bunch of republicans to vacation in Colorado, vote red, and leave. Things would probably change really quick. 😈
Or it could be he’s just stupid and says things off the cuff when asked a question about things like moving the Allstar game.
Or he could be a pos for purposely driving that wedge into baseball fans for partisan politics.
Either way, I went from ambivalent to hating the guy.
~ Kathleen Madigan
~ Born: September 30, 1965 Florissant, MO
~ “Civil War Again”
~ Bothering Jesus is Billboards #1 comedy album in the world,
~ Published on Mar 1, 2018
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eTpG_EUmXr…
Now does anyone actually believe the Government, (even at the State and local levels), couldn't create a convenient, secure, and accurate way for every legal voter in the Country to cast their ballot if that was the goal?
The really wild thing about the ID is not only how permissive things are with voting, but practically encouraged.”
Up until here, I’d managed to resist posting in this trollbait but this point brought me in. There’s a significant difference between being able to vote and having ID. Huge. The biggest. Voting is a constitutional right. Having a driver’s license, a passport or selling things on Amazon is a privilege. Everyone should be able to vote if they are legal. It should be EASIER than doing any of those things. Not harder. That’s different than compromising a secure election.
You don’t need to drive to live in a city so you shouldn’t be forced to go through the six month process of getting a drivers license to vote, the cost of getting a car to take your road test, etc. It’s your right to vote. Requiring a picture and reducing the number of polling places disadvantages “poor people who live in cities” which is in a practical effect, people who aren’t white.
In Maryland, your voter registration card can be your ID. To be fair, I heard Gov Kemp say the bill provided for free picture voting ID. If that’s correct and without other impediments, then it’s a good aspect of the bill.
A major reason for longer lines in predominantly A-A areas is the high frequency of filling out provisional ballots because of lack of ID. This holds up the lines for everyone.
By far the most common form of ID is a Driver's License. A-A's are much less likely to have a license because they are less likely to be drivers. They either live in a city (more common for A-A's) or cannot afford a car and have no need for a license.
"In Orange County, Calif., about 92 percent of white voters had driver’s licenses, compared with only 84 percent of Latino voters and 81 percent of “other” voters. A 2005 study of Wisconsin similarly found that while about 80 percent of white residents had licenses, only about half of African-American and Hispanic residents had licenses."
(It is not clear how SS and other benefits are processed, but I know SS, Medicare and Medicaid ID's do not have photos. A guess is that birth certificates or some other form of ID are used on a one-time basis to establish such services.)
Then I found this tidbit in a Wisconsin study about people with Driver's Licenses:
"The Wisconsin study found that an estimated 8 percent of Hispanic adults and 17 percent of African-American adults had no current license but had a recent suspension or revocation. Almost half of suspended driver’s licenses were due to failure to pay outstanding fines, which may explain why poor people are less likely to have licenses."
So putting all this together:
African Americans are poor, so they can't or won't pay their traffic tickets, so they lose their licenses which are their only form of ID, so they have to fill out provisional ballots and and that causes the line to jam up at predominantly African American polling places.
So let's defund the police so they don't get traffic tickets and don't lose their licenses and that will make voting lines shorter.
Sigh.
There are provisions of the Georgia law that restrict efforts to get out the vote that were predominantly used by African American churches.
- The churches would organize bus and shuttle service from Sunday services to early voting polling places. The Georgia law restricts Sunday voting.
- Because of the longer lines (see above) the churches would organize water and snack distribution in the long lines. This is now explicitly prohibited.
- Because of the long lines (see above) African American voters could not as easily miss time from work. They took advantage of absentee/early voting.
From the web site for the November election. You had to type in your identification number.
"Follow the portal prompts to request your ballot online. You will need submit your first and last name, date of birth, driver's license or state-issued identification number, county of residence, address, phone number, and email address. For primary elections, you will need to request a Democrat, Republican, or Non-Partisan ballot."
🍿
~ Papi_Chulo, TUSCL, August 14, 2020
~ White (Cuban) guy residing in Miami, FL
^ Sad but so true Papi.
~ Warrior15, TUSCL, August 14, 2020
~ Just a Monger looking for some Action.
~ San Jose Guy, TUSCL, January 7, 2020
You’re right, you didn’t say DL. It’s the typical argument that it’s so easy to produce ID, usually a DL, but that disfavors the poor. That was the point I was trying to make and didn’t intentionally mean to point my finger in your face. And as you know, I’m not white, just mostly white. 😆
You are putting an excessive strain on my desire and ability to love all my brothers! :((
SJG"
~ San_jose_Gay April 1, 2021
And then you know you're winning!"
~ Greta Tintin Eleonora Ernman Thunberg
~ Born 3 January 2003 Stockholm, Sweden
Titles and Awards:
* TIME'S 25 most influential teens of 2018, December 2018, an annual list compiled by Time magazine of the most influential teenagers in the world that year.[196]
* Fryshuset scholarship, 2018, for Young Role Model of the Year.
* Nobel Peace Prize nomination, 2019, by three deputies of the Norwegian parliament. Again in 2020 by two Swedish lawmakers.
* Swedish Woman of the Year (Årets Svenska Kvinna), March 2019, awarded by the Swedish Women's Educational Association to "a Swedish woman who, through her accomplishments, has represented and brought attention to the Sweden of today in the greater world".
* Rachel Carson Prize, March 2019, awarded to a woman who has distinguished herself in outstanding work for the environment in Norway or internationally.
* Goldene Kamera film and television awards, March 2019, special Climate Action Award. Thunberg dedicated the prize to the activists protesting against the destruction of the Hambach Forest, which is threatened by lignite mining.
* Fritt Ord Award, April 2019, shared with Natur og Ungdom, which "celebrates freedom of speech". Thunberg donated her share of the prize money to a lawsuit seeking to halt Norwegian oil exploration in the Arctic.
* TIME 100, April 2019, by Time magazine, an annual list of the 100 most influential people in the world for that year.
* Laudato si' Prize, April 2019, awarded under the second encyclical of Pope Francis, "on care for our common home".
* Doctor honoris causa (honorary doctorate), May 2019, conferred by the Belgian, University of Mons for "contribution...to raising awareness on sustainable development."
* Ambassador of Conscience Award, June 2019, Amnesty International's most prestigious award, for her leadership in the climate movement, shared with Fridays for Future.
* The Geddes Environment Medal, July 2019, by the Royal Scottish Geographical Society, for "an outstanding practical, research or communications contribution to conservation and protection of the natural environment and the development of sustainability".
* Honorary Fellowship of the Royal Scottish Geographical Society, July 2019, automatically conferred with the Geddes award.
* Right Livelihood Award, September 2019, from the Right Livelihood Foundation and known as Sweden's alternative Nobel Prize, one of four 2019 winners, "for inspiring and amplifying political demands for urgent climate action reflecting scientific facts".
* Keys to the City of Montréal, September 2019, by Mayor of Montréal Valérie Plante.
* Nelloptodes gretae, October 2019, a newly identified species of beetle is named for Greta Thunberg in an academic paper by entomologist Michael Darby for her outstanding contribution in raising awareness of environmental issues and because the beetle's antennae bear a passing resemblance to Thunberg's pigtails.
* International Children's Peace Prize, October 2019, shared with 14-year-old Divina Maloum from Cameroon, awarded by the KidsRights Foundation.
* Maphiyata echiyatan hin win (Woman Who Came from the Heavens), Lakota tribal name conferred, October 2019, at Standing Rock Indian Reservation, following support for the Dakota Access pipeline opposition, after being invited by Tokata Iron Eyes, a 16-year-old Lakota climate activist.
* Nordic Council Environment Prize, October 2019. Thunberg declined to accept the award or the prize money of DKK 350,000 (€47,000 as of October 2019) stating that Nordic countries were not doing enough to cut emissions.
* Time Person of the Year, December 2019, by Time magazine, the first recipient born in the 21st century and the youngest ever. For succeeding in "creating a global attitudinal shift, transforming millions of vague, middle-of-the-night anxieties into a worldwide movement calling for urgent change." And: "For sounding the alarm about humanity's predatory relationship with the only home we have, for bringing to a fragmented world a voice that transcends backgrounds and borders, for showing us all what it might look like when a new generation leads."
* Glamour Woman of the Year Award 2019, 12 November 2019, by Glamour magazine. Accepted by Jane Fonda, quoting Greta as saying "If a Swedish, teenage, science nerd who has shopstop, refuses to fly and has never worn makeup or been to a hairdresser can be chosen a Woman of the Year by one of the biggest fashion magazines in the world then I think almost nothing is impossible".
* Nature's 10, 2019, December 2019, an annual list of ten "people who mattered" in science, produced by the scientific journal Nature, specifically, for being a "climate catalyst: A Swedish teenager [who] brought climate science to the fore as she channeled her generation's rage."
* Forbes list of The World's 100 Most Powerful Women, 2019
* Craspedotropis gretathunbergae Schilthuizen et al., 2020, a new species of land snail from Borneo described in the family Cyclophoridae is named after Thunberg and another new freshwater snail from New Zealand, Opacuincola gretathunbergae Verhaege & Haase, 2021, is dedicated to Thunberg.
* Human Act Award, on Earth Day, 22 April 2020, by the Human Act Foundation, for "her fearless and determined efforts to mobilize millions of people around the world to fight climate change". The USD100,000 prize money was donated to UNICEF and doubled by the Foundation.
* Thunberga greta, June 2020, a new species of huntsman spider in a new genus Thunberga gen nov named after Thunberg by arachnologist Peter Jäger.
* Gulbenkian Prize for Humanity, 2020, the first recipient of this prize. Through her foundation, Thunberg donated the €1 million prize money "to charitable projects combatting the climate and ecological crisis and to support people facing the worst impacts, particularly in the Global South".
Works:
~ Scenes from the Heart (2018), with her sister, father and mother.
~ No One Is Too Small to Make a Difference (May 2019), a collection of her climate action speeches, with the earnings being donated to charity.
~ Warrior15, TUSCL, August 14, 2020
~ Just a Monger looking for some Action.
Err...I didn’t actually know that . Oops 😅
The reality is:
“Laws to limit the black vote may not seem racist on the surface but may be racist in practice.”
~ jackslash
~ older strip club customer, dancers often tell him he resemble a movie star. The movie star is Woody Allen.
I'm saying that being white is clearly better.
Who could even argue?”
“Now, if you're white and you don't admit that it's great, you're an asshole.”
~ Louis Székely
~ White Privileged stand up comedian
~ Born Sep 12, 1967 Washington, D.C., U.S.
Lots of common sense people of all backgrounds could be swayed to elect common sense republicans. But they have to play the positive side not just block votes from neighborhoods they lose in. They need to dive in there and convince people why they should be elected. The regular voters don’t change much but the ones who don’t vote often are more persuadable. Instead they take on these non-issues and open them selves up to be tarred as racists.
Others have pointed out that it's also a constitutional right to bear arms which requires ID and background checks.
We are in a pandemic - and we finally have a vaccine - but communities of color are fearful to get vaccinated. Why? A microchip implanted?
They have prominent African American people getting vaccinated on TV so others feel safe. The vaccine has gone through a testing process - and millions have gotten it safely already. They put up vaccine locations directly outside of NYCHA buildings - those are the places where your tax dollars go to die. But folks won’t get vaccinated.
Why? Because of two factors - they are uninformed and lazy - and possibly stupid.
This is the same reason why democrats object to anything that requires one of their potential voters to lift a finger. They know their supporters are lazy fucks. They don’t want them to have to bring an ID to the polling locations or to ever lift a finger!
Here is a revolutionary idea - and it’s going to piss off many folks - but if folks could vote by Nintendo or Xbox - everyone would vote! You get a cool video game look to vote - and you can sit on your sofa while smoking a bong - in your sweat pants - in your free government housing project - and vote for someone who will keep the government spending going!
Come on CJ Kent - tell me why that’s a bad thing? All those non-contributors can have a voice to vote in more welfare loving, wasteful spending politicians!
They can sleep through the gunfire all day long - and play their video games - and listen to their rap music - and order food on some app using a credit card they will default on - as the await their reparations from the enslavement of their people (people who aren’t related to them in any way)!
It’s more waste and more free stuff - and it will never end!
Take some initiative. Get a job. Work through the system of this world. Nobody is going to hire a CEO off the couch in a project! Those folks have worked for years and learned a lot - and built something. I know folks will call my post racist - but it’s more about getting off your ass and working!
In NYC there is a political endorsement being made by Eric Garner’s mother! Holy shit! She gave birth to a criminal - who was morbidly obese - had diabetes because of his obesity - and he was selling cigarettes illegally - and she’s qualified to endorse a mayoral candidate?! Wtf?!
That’s not true. Can’t I buy a gun from my friend, some dude on Craigslist or at a gun show without ID or a background check? And to state it again, I’ve never said you don’t need ID to vote. I said you shouldn’t need a drivers license or passport. I’m in favor of free voter ID issued with voter registration, like what Gov Kemp (if true) says the GA law does.
Georgia has had free voter ID cards for years.
You wrote and I quote:
“Here is a revolutionary idea - and it’s going to piss off many folks - but if folks could vote by Nintendo or Xbox - everyone would vote! You get a cool video game look to vote - and you can sit on your sofa while smoking a bong - in your sweat pants - in your free government housing project - and vote for someone who will keep the government spending going!
Come on CJ Kent - tell me why that’s a bad thing? All those non-contributors can have a voice to vote in more welfare loving, wasteful spending politicians!”
To answer your question; it is not completely a bad thing:
“I think we all can agree that there are a lot of illegals that are already here and work hard and we would like that they stayed and...
I also think we all agree that there are a lot Americans that haven’t really pan out.”
“I said we turn illegal immigration into a reality show where we vote people in and vote people out.”
“Americans will get involved then, then they will care,”
“So we just start voting and Ryan Seacrest can announce the results at the end of American Idol; he will be like:
“Joining this week is Juan Gonzales he’s being hiding in a garage in Buffalo for the past eleven and a half years, but apparently he is an eye doctor.
Leaving us this week, she has eight new babies and six she already couldn’t afford, say goodbye to Octomom America, say goodbye.”
~ Kathleen Madigan
~ Born: September 30, 1965 Florissant, MO
Video clip in you tube:
m.youtube.com
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WZOHV5v3WJ…
If they applied the same standard to both, they'd be handing out firearms like free samples of shampoo at the supermarket.
Aren't the voting places run by local county and city governments? Blacks mostly live in areas run by Democrats. If there are long lines it would only hurt the party in power at higher state and federal levels.
>even making it illegal to provide water to voters standing in the long lines
It was already illegal to hand out anything to someone standing in a voter line by federal law. The election officials are allowed to provide water.
When I voted last year elderly and sick people were moved to the front of the line.
There's only ONE rational explanation for the left being so strongly opposed to voter ID, and it's because they want to CHEAT. Requiring ID to cast a vote doesn't deprive anyone except for CHEATERS. And since there's no logical way for them to win the argument, they do what they always do: cry racism.
OK, I understand the reasons it may be harder for minorities and the poor to get an ID. I get it. MAKE IT EASIER to get them an ID. Problem solved. Excuse eliminated.
I posted this earlier in the thread. In one study, One of every six African American adults have been issued a DL but it is suspended or revoked (and therefore is not accepted as an ID. The ballot will be rejected because the ID does not come back as valid). The most common reason is unpaid traffic fines.
You wrote, and I quote:
“Here is a revolutionary idea...”
Please tell us your thoughts about this “revolutionary idea”:
“Death to the fascist insects that prey on the lives of the people”
~ Patricia Campbell Hearst aka Tania (Born February 20, 1954 San Francisco, California)
~ Soldier in the People’s Army.
The argument (not saying I agree with it) is that it is hard for them to get to DMV during business hours, especially on public transportation.
So how about issuing them at post offices? It would give the PO another source of revenue (from the government paying them to perform that service). Now you have several or dozens of locations rather than one countywide facility.
Wtf is so difficult about getting a sandwich or water bottle in advance, and bringing it with you ? I didn't see any constraints against people bringing their own food or water with them prior to getting in line.
All these later I still recall the exact comment he made, "You know who we told them to vote for" he said wit a big smile on his face. Those "voters" probably weren't even registered.
Shit like that is illegal yet has been going on for years in big democratic cities while their politicians silently approve and the law is ignored and in most cases the media ignores it.
I don't have much doubt that the real agenda of whoever is handing out food and water in poll lines aren't doing it out of kindness, they're doing it to coach and prod people to vote for their candidates, democrats.
That's why they scream and whine and use the race card trying to shut up any dissenters to their schemes.
Winning future elections informs the “open border” strategy as well. “When we make it possible, vote for the people who got you here”
(Although some are so stupid and shallow they don’t get that their support came from other taxpayers, they just think it came magically from some pandering politician p.o.s. like doddering Uncle Joe)
I don't necessarily agree with everything I say, write or quote...
Quotations are used by me as a means of inspiration and to invoke philosophical thoughts from the reader.
Pragmatically speaking, quotations can also be used as language games (in the Wittgensteinian sense of the term) to manipulate social order and the structure of society
“Like everything metaphysical the harmony between thought and reality is to be found in the grammar of the language.”
~ Ludwig Wittgenstein
~ Austrian-British philosopher
~ Born: April 26, 1889, Vienna, Austria
~ Died: April 29, 1951, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Ludwig said it all...
Umm...
Bullshit! You've posted that same mantra over and over and who exactly have you inspired?
Nobody!
You post what you do because you're a fucking troll, that's why you've been banned at least once and I await the next one you FUCKHEAD!
The people that still want to mail a ballot have more stringent requirements.
Haters will see you walk on water and say it’s because you can’t swim.
Haters are angry, because the truth contradicts the lie they live...
:D
To suggest Black people can’t get ID is condescending to the point of overt racism.
You associating not having an id with being black shows your racism
Also Republicans: Not like that!
Their “strategy” to maintain their power is by diluting the voting power of every other non-white American group...