I rejected this review but still got published - what do you think ?

This is a shopping list, not a review. I would have rejected.

Not sure what the club is like? Sounds more like a vacation plan. I would have rejected.

I would have rejected it as well.

Lol

Might as well have taken a picture of the menu at the jernt.

I would have rejected as well. To me, a review is supposed to be about your personal experience at the club, good or bad, with specific details, particularly regarding your experience with the women (isn't that why you go?). The goal, perhaps, should be to convince others why they should or should not frequent this club. Simply taking five minutes to jot down a laundry list of costs, in my opinion, is not worth four weeks of VIP privileges. Then again, I'd rather have this than a complete fabrication just to get VIP.

I think this may possibly be a fake review - this is his 1st time to HK and this is all he can come up with after going to a club like HK - I get the sense he just got some info from reading it somewhere (perhaps the discussion board) and just copied it to his "review" - i.e. I have my doubts he was even there else he would have given specifics about his 1st visit to a legendary club

It does provide info but not new info. Papi, you may be right - it seems to be a rehash of info that has been posted many times.

On the other hand, some members have commented that they reject reviews that do not include the cost of drinks. A person could get whiplash just trying to satisfy everyone.

I think it’s fine. There are 1000 reviews of HK, what else do you really need to know?

I felt like I was reading an expense report from one of my sales team. I would have rejected the review and most of the expenses.

having a little bit of detail of his interaction with the club and girls would be beneficial.

Can you see who approved the review? Thought that was a new feature.

I would have accepted it.

I would have rejected this. I am looking for a review of a club, not a corporate travel expense report.

Ricky Boy would have rejected it because it doesn’t have expenses listed for a three piece suit and a fake membership card for the American Institute of Chemical Engineers.

I wouldn't have done either. I don't read reviews for border town whore houses. Their basically all the same.

@CMI

The review-publishers are listed near the end of the OP (or search for the word "publisher")

shadow. HK is not your normal border whorehouse. you can easily treated as a regular American style strip club if you want to.

friggin Siri. ‘treated’ should be ‘treat it’.

I would have rejected the review too.

But since it did get published, the reviewer did a decent job of getting bang for his buck for a first time visit.

Since there aren't any fichas expensed out he didn't spend too much time getting to know the bargirls, just going arriba.

i’ve done that a few times… (To great success by the way!!!)

there are two particular girls that are easy nine’s... even 9.5’s... I don’t dare delay when I see them. they are extremely busy. I wouldn’t doubt that they get 10 Arriba’s per shift. I grab them when I can.

It does cover costs. :)

@misterwonderful

Arriba with a ficha is risky, but I've done it and had some pretty great experiences too.

*without (not with)... Lol

oh yeah. Believe me. I know.

I like reading the unpublished reviews, but pass judgement only on those reviews that describe clubs that I have been to or reviews that are very well written. I have seen a few bad reviews that were passed by PLs that later comment that they have never been to the club. Is that because their ego makes them want to “raise their hand” even when they know they don’t know the right answer?

Will he use this free vip to read hk reviews and actually plan a trip there instead of dreaming.

Would have made a good discussion topic, but lacks as a review.

@anislee Mikeyem is a longtime reviewer I doubt he really cares about VIP, I didn’t care much for a review done this way, but even though I read many of the unpublished reviews I very rarely vote on clubs I haven’t actually been to.