OT: "New York Strip Steak" OR "Ribeye Steak"

avatar for VeryBigDawg
VeryBigDawg
Georgia
Medium rare New York Strip Steak with fresh sauteed mushrooms.

33 comments

Jump to latest
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
9 years ago
Always Ribeye but if you want the best of the best its a large Porterhouse, for two served by Peter Luger in Brooklyn, N.Y. since I think 1897.
avatar for ButterMan
ButterMan
9 years ago
Ribeye! But I prefer Filet mignon or porter house with a nice lobster tail.
avatar for ime
ime
9 years ago
New York Strip, though lately been grilling sirloin medium rare and slathered with chimmichuri.
avatar for vincemichaels
vincemichaels
9 years ago
Make mine a filet, medium well done with asparagus tips in a bernaise sauce.
avatar for flagooner
flagooner
9 years ago
Ribeye, but it has to have the bone-in. Medium rare. Heaven.
avatar for mikeya02
mikeya02
9 years ago
Prime rib, medium rare, with a lobster tail and a loaded baked potato.
avatar for Dominic77
Dominic77
9 years ago
Ribeye is pretty good. I prefer Filet Mignon, rare, with scallops. The wife also likes Filet, medium rare with lobster tail. With grilled zucchini. For dessert a nice slice of chocolate cake to share. I usually enjoy it with a dewars and soda. She has a glass of wine, recommended by the waiter/waitress.
avatar for elvis2
elvis2
9 years ago
Bone-in ribeye. medium well w/ onions and mushrooms. Salad, 'taters, and asparagus. Sweet tea, and Key Lime Pie.

Lately, i have really enjoyed a good hamburger steak,and much cheaper.
avatar for rattdog
rattdog
9 years ago
ribeye. filet fignon. hmm. yeah. could be a change of pace this week as well as next. might be better of spending my money on that than the duds i've been encountering lately at the clubs.
avatar for rh48hr
rh48hr
9 years ago
Either one for me medium. I love me some steak. :-)
avatar for jester214
jester214
9 years ago
Any kind of steak is a win with me.

Medium bone-ribeye over a strip though.
avatar for shadowcat
shadowcat
9 years ago
Flank steak ala Carne Asada.
avatar for JohnSmith69
JohnSmith69
9 years ago
Damn. Now I've got the munchies. Where the fuck am I going to find a steak at this hour when I'm not in a hotel?

And the answer is ribeye.
avatar for shadowcat
shadowcat
9 years ago
JS69 - A lot of grocery stores are still open. :)
avatar for JohnSmith69
JohnSmith69
9 years ago
No fucking way Im gonna drive in this condition. And no Ubers I looked.

Cheese its are awesome. But nowhere near as good as a juicy ribeye, lobster tail, and baked potato.
avatar for NinaBambina
NinaBambina
9 years ago
I prefer a filet mignon. Medium rare or medium.

Side of potatoes and I will be in heaven.
avatar for pensionking
pensionking
9 years ago
prime rib -- lawry's.
otherwise, ribeye.
avatar for seaboardrr
seaboardrr
9 years ago
Neither of us have ever understood the fascination people have for ribeyes. I always get us porterhouses at the local meat market but Mrs. Sea prefers just the filet part.
avatar for ATACdawg
ATACdawg
9 years ago
I'm with Shadow. Either flank steak or skirt steak, marinated for at least 4 hours in a combination of Mexican spices and grilled about three to four minutes per side. Slicing it thin across the grain is essential to keep it tender. The flavor is terrific due to the fat content and it's usually less expensive than the premium cuts.
avatar for georgmicrodong
georgmicrodong
9 years ago
Of those two? Ribeye, bone in. In general though, any well cooked, reasonably seasoned steak will be welcome.
avatar for rickdugan
rickdugan
9 years ago
Bone-in ribeye, medium rare, with a loaded baked potato, sauteed mushrooms and creamed spinach (the real stuff).
avatar for Clubber
Clubber
9 years ago
Not a steak person, but if I have to, a filet, rare.
avatar for DaOnion
DaOnion
9 years ago
Ditto Nina. Filet, medium rare, with potato. Maybe add a side of sauteed spinach with garlic too. Also, a shrimp cocktail to start off with.
avatar for chessmaster
chessmaster
9 years ago
Ribeye well done
avatar for VeryBigDawg
VeryBigDawg
9 years ago
That bone in Rib Eye is mighty fine eating.
avatar for vincemichaels
vincemichaels
9 years ago
JohnSmith69, I do deliveries, for you, a TUSCL regular, I'll forego my usual charge.
avatar for Papi_Chulo
Papi_Chulo
9 years ago
Damn – I’m too getting the munchies.

I don’t eat steak regularly – sorta when in the mood and have a good appetite – usually will go w/ the Filet Mignon (it’s fairly flavorful and fairly tender; I don’t like cuts of meat w/ too much fat or stuff in it that makes me feel like I’m biting into ligaments)
avatar for Clubber
Clubber
9 years ago
Papi,

You and me both. The filet has it's fat marbled.
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
9 years ago
^^^To Clubber & Papi if you get a chance to try a Prime grade A Porterhouse steak the fat is very much mixed in the marbling and if it is cooked right over very high heat, over 700 degrees, which is an easy temperature to reach on any quality Bar-B-Q grill the Porterhouse cut steak which is the meat that the Filet & and the Ribeye are carved from by a butcher, the fat will run out during the cooking and cause flare-ups on the grill imparting a great flavor to the meat cooked to your taste, Rare (mostly pink center), Medium (much less pink center) or Well (no pink at all) I guarantee, unless you just don't like beef you will love it as I believe it to be the best of any type of steak.
avatar for Clubber
Clubber
9 years ago
25,

Been there, done that. At " weekly steak night" when I was dating my wife, her mother used to get them for the whole family, Nine counting me. She used to have the market guy grind mine and cook it as a burger. I still prefer the filet.

As I said, I'm not much of a steak guy. When I take my wife out for a steak, I almost always get salmon, and if not, a filet.
avatar for twentyfive
twentyfive
9 years ago
Club I'm sure that burger was delicious probably was triple the cost of hamburger meat.
avatar for flagooner
flagooner
9 years ago
28-day dry aged bone-in ribeye, medium rare.

Much more aging than that and it gets a bit too gamey for my tastes.
avatar for Clubber
Clubber
9 years ago
25,

'twas! :)
You must be a member to leave a comment.Join Now