Innie pussies for sure, but its not a deal breaker if its not.
Nipples, I'd say I prefer normal or small from your list, but its really not something I care about.
Breasts, those depend a lot on the girls frame. The left hand side of the boob shape pic is probably what I'd go for most. I tend to prefer smaller over larger, but there's a real steep curve when they got too tiny. Saggy/droopy are generally a deal breaker, but thats it.
Asses are pretty important for me too, a pancake ass or a big bowl of jelly back there are both turn offs. A firm ass that's big enough to stand out from the back/leg but not big enough to draw attention to itself is ideal for me.
Flat stomach's are good too. I've gotta be the fat one in the pair of us. I'm not that slim so there's some wiggle room there but not that much.
All in all, fitting together is the most important part. A bunch of good parts is a much better package than some really nice ones paired with some really bad ones.