Advertisement

USS Harry S Truman

Regarding the collision of a bulk carrier and our aircraft carrier:

  1. How does a ship of that size get this close to the carrier, assuming the strike group was also around?

  2. I'm not saying the bulk carrier should have been lit up, but, back to the first question, how did it get that close?

comments (4)

Jump to latest
Avatar for Rightfield
Rightfield

Remember a couple years ago, two large navy ships were involved in collisions with merchant vessels bad enough that sailors in their bunks got killed? Like you, I was dumbfounded this could happen. Of course, ships are slow to respond to control inputs. I was told once it takes more than a mile to stop a loaded iron ore boat from full speed.

As I read more about the navy collisions later, one explanation was that ships are now controlled by touch screens. If a collision becomes imminent, instead of grabbing an obvious lever which gives tactical feedback, you have to swipe at the fricking touch screen. Sounds like it could be true; and a problem.

Also, on the seas, there is an element of "chicken" that is played with big important ships, regardless of who has right-of-way. Disclaimer: I am not a military pilot. I only pilot some civilian vessels.

Avatar for ATACdawg
ATACdawg

It's really worse than simply taking a mile to stop. The reality is that you can draw a semicircle centered on your course when you go to full power reverse and the ship will stop somewhere in that semicircle.

Avatar for jaybud999
jaybud999

Why do you guys think that ship wasn't blasted up? I have ZERO experience or knowledge of military/civilian ship operations, but wouldn't a non strike group ship NOT be allowed to even move within that range?

Avatar for Rightfield
Rightfield

I suppose even war ships get pretty close to other traffic in the tight shipping lanes. The warships have a pretty good idea whether another vessel is hostile or not. If there is any blasting to be done, it would be further than at ramming distance.

Related Discussions

  • States / Cities that COULD have a great strip club scene but don't.

    I am wondering in your own words what are some states and / or cities that have some or all of the right ingredients for having a truly kickass strip club scene but for whatever reason be it cultural, zoning restrictions...

  • Early Strip Club Memories

    Prior to January of 2024, when I started SCing on a regular basis, I had only been to a strip club twice, summer of 1999 and spring of 2000. There was quite a contrast between these two clubs. One was the higher end,...

  • The end of an era

    We are all familiar with a couple of adages, the first that comes to mind would be that all good things must come to an end. Unfortunately, a more appropriate adage would be something akin to how my participation in the...

  • How many people do you think read the board but don't post?

    I notice if you post something that is right up someone's alley, despite not hearing from them for months or years, you might see them chime in less than 2 seconds. What it is that? But what about those who don't even a ...

  • 18 reasons to go to strip clubs

    "For many, the gentleman’s club is simply a place to unwind, where loud music, cheap beer, and attractive women intersect. It’s a setting that offers an easy escape from day-to-day life, a spot to spend time with friends...

  • Stuff you like to over indulge in

    The people that know you, sort of associate you with ODing on whatever that is. -When I'm on the road I always get this big jug of whole milk be it in the car or walking around the city. I love milk and I just think it...

  • The R.O.B.

    As I rescued my Titleist from the bottom of the cup I heard a tearing sound and immediately thought: "ya tore your pants fatso", but no, my pants were fine, the sound was my knee, ending golf season prematurely. My broth...

  • Visited My First Club - Glad I Did, But Felt I Rushed It

    Well today I did it. After going back and forth in my head if I should or shouldn't for the last few weeks, I finally visited my first SC. I honestly wish I hadn't waited so long to do so. I was only there for a short p...

Advertisement