The battle continues.
shadowcat
Atlanta suburb
The Columbus Dispatch reports (http://bit.ly/1Lnk5ok ) New Beginnings Ministries Pastor William Dunfee filed the lawsuit against Foxhole strip club owner Thomas George and his employees on Sept. 4 in Columbus federal court.
The suit claims the topless protesters violated the Warsaw church's First Amendment right to religious freedom and the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act.
Dunfee is asking for an injunction ordering the protesters to not block church entrances, intrude on its property or intimidate parishioners.
George called the claims "very false." He organized the protests after losing a suit against the church in 2009 for picketing outside his establishment.
Got something to say?
Start your own discussion
20 comments
Latest
Well, if the claims are "very" false then they should take some time to reconsider.
They should have a right to attend church services if they stop them from sitting outside on the curb. Maybe without the signs though.
If you want to really understand the history of this:
http://www.amazon.com/God-vs-Gavel-Relig…
Religious groups have been getting away with all manner of stuff. Sometimes it is literally rape and murder.
SJG
https://sites.google.com/site/sjgportal/…
To an extent they style their actions like a protest. But they aren't actually saying that the laws are wrong. They are saying that their religion places them above the law. This is not the same. They are actually asking government to shred the Constitution and endorse them and submit to them.
One of them, "I work for Jesus, so I can do whatever I want."
This was an issue with Martin Luther King too. He right away went with the Montgomery Bus Boycott. But he opposed the Lunch Counter Sit Ins because that was illegal and he claimed, "Un-Christian".
Later he reversed. But he claimed to be following Gandhi, but he did not seem to understand Gandhi. King was always falling into this trap of claiming to be morally superior, and hence above the law.
Gandhi was never saying anything of the sort. It is like Cornell West says of him, "Non-violence was a tactic, but not a strategy. He pursued non-violence, but a violent option was always available."
King made non-violence and moral superiority the objective.
It was like this up to the Edmund Pettis Bridge matter, and the Voting Rights Act passage. But then after this he did change. During the last two years of his life he did speak against the War In Vietnam and against Capitalism itself.
SJG
https://sites.google.com/site/sjgportal/…
"To an extent they style their actions like a protest. But they aren't actually saying that the laws are wrong. They are saying that their religion places them above the law. This is not the same. They are actually asking government to shred the Constitution and endorse them and submit to them."
Now yes, those intent on a protest are not always going to be lawful. And non-violent civil disobedience is a tradition in this country and most others. But the Born Again groups usually don't admit that they are being unlawful, and they aren't trying to say that the laws are unjust. Rather they are saying that because of their religion, they are above the law.
Then also they are saying that because local government and the population aren't lining up behind them in their religious views, that the population is immoral / unsaved / without Jesus.
Now yes, these groups are entitled to their views. But it is essential that local government not capitulate in any way. They must not endorse religion and this idea that they are above the law. They must enforce the law the same as they would with anyone else. They cannot sign on to the mission.
Unfortunately local government is usually taken in. They have police with tear gas, body armor, and assault rifles, but they are afraid of the political consequences of tangling with Bible Brandishers. So I end up having lots of conversations with City Attorneys and Elected Officials.
One group which really came into it's own in San Francisco was Food Not Bombs. They destroyed the mayor ship of Frank Jordan.
http://foodnotbombs.net/new_site/
But they are not saying that they are above the law. They are simply breaking the law. Sometimes they get jailed. But the city is not doing anything wrong by looking the other way and allowing it. That is tolerance.
But Born Again groups, in the 25 years since FNB started in San Francisco, imitate it with these park feeds. The Born Again groups have a very different agenda. In allowing them, the city is not showing tolerance, it is showing spinelessness and it is trampling on the Constitution.
SJG
Stones, ft/ Christina Aguilera
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rs9DnK-U…
first and most obvious is that you said san_jose_guy "works". of course everyone knows that is not just improbable but it flat out ain't ever going to happen. just ask his ex-mail order bride if you have any doubts.
second even the ACLU has some pride. the day they associate with the likes of san_jose_guy will be the day that hell is frozen solid.
But most of the events put on by Food Not Bombs are illegal. They are intended to be illegal. They are following the example of Gandhi and his Salt March. They are breaking seemingly unimportant laws, for the purpose of showing that our society is set up wrong and has the wrong priorities.
So often the authorities just do nothing.
In San Francisco, Mayor Frank Jordan, a former Police Chief, had come into office pledging to crack down on the homeless. So he took the baiting from Food Not Bombs, and then several times per week there were dozens of police out at city hall and there were police on horseback and police were throwing people to the ground and seizing huge pots of soup.
So Foot Not Bombs had as it's number two man, long time activist, Diamond Dave Whitaker. His job was to do the talking when everyone else was in jail. So time after time they would talk with Diamond Dave opposite Frank Jordan's Press Secretary Noah Griffin, on Michael Krazney's KQED Forum.
Eventually Griffin would resign and Jordan became a one term Mayor.
But in the wake of this, lots of Born Again Groups have emerged, doing what FNB did, illegal park feeds. So you could say that it is civil disobedience, a political protest, so better just to let them do it.
But the Born Again groups don't see it as illegal. And the cities often don't either. They think the doctrine of Free Speech protects it. They are wrong, Free Speech has never meant access to any particular place. All it means is that the gov't can make a law against your specific group or your specific message.
So what I was always having to explain to San Jose Officials was that if you think they have a right to do this in the park because of Free Speech, then why don't you let them do it in the Mayor's Office? By your reasoning, Free Speech means that you can't lock them out.
So eventually saner people interceded for the city and they admitted that this violates city ordinances. So it is just like Food Not Bombs. But still, do they want to do anything about it? And still, there are some with cities who try to protect the city administration itself, by refusing to admit that the city has any legal obligations at all.
If one is going to allow unlawful acts because they are part of a non-violent political protest, then one will want to look at what is actually being done, and why.
Food Not Bombs feeds people because it is protesting against our society's priorities.
Most of these Born Again groups feed people while subjecting them to insults and haranguing, and they do this because they are protesting against the Separation of Church and State. They are protesting because they believe that they above the law. They are protesting against the First Amendment.
SJG
https://sites.google.com/site/sjgportal/…
Preacher and the Slave
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8qoB1Xw…
Like a Hurricane
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-WMbP1R…
well you’ve got the “postal” part correct
People find these psychopaths interesting and they write true and fictional stories based on them because they aren't really any different from anybody else. So is this what you go through life worrying about, and worrying more about appearances than actuality?
SJG
https://sites.google.com/site/sjgportal/…
Stones, Milwaukee, 2015
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6QsmJ0S…