Who could do better, the good girl in a bad club, or bad girl in a good club?

I had this thought when getting a dance from one of my favorites the other day. She told me that someone said she broke the club rules and was being watched for a while. I've never known her to do that - in fact, she made it clear what the rules were when I got my first dance ever with her. Incidently, I think it could be a case of mistaken identity as there is another girl that almost looks like her that I know bends the club rules. Biggest difference is breast size. But I digress.

Do you think a girl that is used to playing by the rules in a conservative club would fare well in a more liberal club? And would a girl that bends the rules in more liberal clubs be able to last at more conservative clubs?