I have worked in clubs with and without DJs and ultimately there can be many positives to both sides, I personally think a DJ presence is better than none.
My club recently changed from a dancer run free computer that allowed dancers to select their own songs for their stage sets. Well as dancers do love to be independent in every way, the dancers loved this. Even if it meant listening to the same song SEVERAL times because multiple dancers repetitively selected it (at PP that song is Kelly Rowland Motivation BTW). When a dancer did'nt preselect her song and it was her turn and she was called to the stage she danced to whatever was next on Winamp.
Well the club manager bought a Rockola jukebox and payperplay songs. When a dancer wants a song for her stageset she now pays .50cents to $2 per song. (Michael Jackson Rock With You is .50 / Ted Nugent Cat Scratch Fever is $2) Dancers at PP who do not want to pay Rockola have to dance to whatevers playing on Sirius Lithium. Pitiful Princess dancers do not like this lack of song control and lots of forced dancing to Alice in Chains. The customers do not identify with the music (Pearl Jam / Soundgarden) and they do not like that the dancers are unhappy. The club manager likes opening Rockola and seeing the money. Most of the money is from dancers who want to dance to what they want during a stageset. In this truly neighborhood dive, where dancers already pay stagefees daily, they now also pay for their songs individually.
A good DJ would resolve the problems of song repetition, getting dancers to stage, and paying attention to the club needs: happy customers and happy dancers.


Yeah – dancers having to pay to play songs sucks and it’s just a money grab by the owner.
Personally – I hate DJs – can’t stand them for the most part.
I tend to concentrate on the dancers and the music being played is a secondary – personally I have never wanted to leave a SC b/c of the music but have wanted to leave b/c of an annoying or inept DJ – and in some of the black clubs I’ve visited; they sometimes have had a MC which makes it unbearable for me personally (although MCs are rare and I have not seen one in a while).
My pet peeves w/ DJs:
very few are funny but most think they are
talk over the music – talk before a song and hold up the start of the song – even stop a song midway to talk his shit (most of these things are more of the exception than the norm but it happens in dives and particularly in black dives I visit)
cutting songs short (this I assume in on the direction of the manager or owner?) – but I would think this is not an issue with a computer or jukebox sound system
So personally I don’t care very much for DJs – but I think what works for custies are often not the same things that work for the dancers.