The Pony Indy
3551 Lafayette Rd
Indianapolis, IN 46222
Reviews
Submit a ReviewLow key happy hour to unwind after work
Still longing for a place worth stopping off for a couple cocktails on my way home….so I tried the Pony the last two weeks. A weds and a thurs around 5p
I stopped both times because…
Chance073
Sep 21, 2025, 4:05 PM
Mediocre at best
Had a little arrangement in Indy and when that fell through I decided to go to The Pony. I’m more of the thick big booty women of color lover so that’s why I decided to…
2 commentslast: 2 mos ago(docsavage)
Mr Monger
Aug 12, 2025, 3:13 PM
The weather was not that frightful…
Set up a get together on a wintry Friday night at the pony. I forget that central Indiana folk freak out over a few inches of snow, but I knew it was a problem when…
1 commentslast: 10 mos ago(docsavage)
Chance073
Jan 22, 2025, 4:53 PM
A fun night with a divey feel
Visited with a couple friends on a Saturday night. No valet but there’s a parking lot. When you first walk in there’s a hostess to check ID and pay cover. Before you enter a security…
3 commentslast: 10 mos ago(Mr Monger)
Mousitsa
Jan 7, 2025, 3:49 PM
Another Saturday Night and I Ain't Got Nobody
I have been here a few times but it was always on an off peak time so the place was usually pretty slow. A friend called and asked me to come see her on…
DH721
Dec 11, 2024, 3:40 AM
I want more
Im back after my long but eventful hiatus. As a midwester I’m usually around the Chicago, Indy, Detroit area so this week I was Indy and decided to roll the dice and hunt.
The parking…
Mr Monger
Oct 21, 2024, 4:31 PM
Not Bad, But Not My Thing
A recent Saturday night found me at The Pony for the first time in well over a year. I've been skipping the club partly because it's inconveniently-located for me and partly because my previous couple…
2 commentslast: 1 yr ago(Tiredtraveler)
MasterT71
Jun 13, 2024, 11:24 PM
recommended
I arrived late on a recent Monday night. 10-12 cars in the lot. $10 cover charge. Kind of dumb to charge cover on a slow Monday but I get it. Main guy collecting cover and…
2 commentslast: 1 yr ago(docsavage)
captainfun
Aug 17, 2023, 12:34 AM
one of the better options in the area
This club is in Indianapolis which is different from how it is displayed on this site.
I was at the club several weeks ago on a Wednesday night. Surprised to see that the last review…
3 commentslast: 2 yrs ago(racejeff)
captainfun
Jul 8, 2023, 7:23 PM
good club
I had been to this club just one other time around 9 pm on a weekday 4-5 years ago. Had an opportunity to be in Indianapolis last Saturday and was at the club from 11…
captainfun
Sep 26, 2022, 12:59 AM
Hey God Dammit, stop trying to hump the pony! How many times do we gotta say it?
Indianapolis, IN. Tuesday night. Originally wanted to go to Dancers but said fuck that their parking lot was so dead, I knew it'd be a waste. I came here instead on my way through Indy.…
Muddy
Aug 20, 2022, 1:42 AM
Not great, but not bad; felt like it had potential to be better a different night
The Pony was about a fifteen minute drive from downtown. It had a large, free parking lot that wrapped around the back of the club. The nearer side parking was mostly full whenI arrived, but…
schmoe31415
Aug 13, 2022, 12:56 PM


