Inflation: You’re Never Going To Move Again*

^ Yet they’re building single family luxury homes like crazy in my area, starting prices are over one million, and selling out huge subdivisions very quickly. The interest rates are right now pretty average, the low rates of the past few years were an anomaly, when I bought my home rates were right around 7%, and even though I refinanced several times to lower my rate, people are buying homes and selling them at a pretty good clip.

Well, you do live in Floriduh so I understand all the new builds there, that's not happening in the areas I travel in. There's a small pocket here and there but not much. It's confusing to me because there still is a housing shortage where I live.

I agree with what you said on interest rates, historically they aren't "that" bad right now, but they are still higher than what I initially signed up for in the 2000s. For the millennials and handful of Gen Z that are buying houses, these rates look insanely high because they know nothing different. Blame that on short term memory.

I was talking to a banker the other day and he was telling me all these incentives they have for people if they sign up for a home loan or refinance, to me that says they're hurting for business. Completely understandable since I'm sure they still want that COVID business rush they experienced 4 years ago.

^ Despite all the negative news about the housing market it’s still the best way for individuals to get to a comfortable lifestyle. Owning a home is the best investment you can make in your own future with the greatest chance of long term success.

Just as long as they don't start 3D printing 2,500 SQ FT houses for $50,000 in 20 years...

It used to be that every subsequent generation was better off than their parents. I think that has come to an end. Gen Y and Gen Z will be worse off than their parents. Many people in their 20's and 30's can't afford a house or the rising apartment rents and are stuck living with their parents. The middle class is shrinking, and the country is becoming poorer. Now people living in vans and tiny houses (100 to 300 square feet) is considered an accomplishment rather than embarrassment.

There is still a good amount of availability in luxury and upper tier housing, but there is a tight housing market for the poor and working class. Letting in twelve million illegals drives up demand for lower tier rentals and houses. There is a housing crisis in Canada due to the country bringing in the equivalent of one percent of its population as immigrants every single year. Housing can't be built quick enough, resulting in skyrocketing rents and house prices for Canadians.

I'm not a professional economist, but inflation is still rising and interest rates will have to be raised higher if the government is actually serious about getting inflation under control. The government needs to stop spending like a drunk sailor and get it's act together if it doesn't want a loaf of bread to cost the equivalent of a wheelbarrow full of dollars. Force every government agency to cut its budget by twenty percent, stop funding foreign wars, and stop spending billions on "newcomers".

It is intellectually dishonest to use oddities and local geographic data like Florida to argue against national trends and facts. It has been known for a long time that millennials and zoomers will be the first generations to experience a decrease and quality of life compared to their parents.

Inflation continues to rise. The cost of living increases to rise. Government spending increases to rise. The cost of housing and cars and eggs and everything continue to rise. The inflation reduction act has failed, but the Biden administration and Bidenonics have been successful at weakening America and weakening Americans' bank accounts, and continuing the Obama globalist agenda to cut down America to a third world country.

Interest rates are about the same now as when I bought my first house. I had to move to a place where the cost of houses, relative to area salaries, was low. Maybe we should panic about something else. Like ricks having to pay $38 for anal instead of $37.50.

Until just recently, for most of this century, after taxes, your emergency money in a money market account would actually lose value accounting for inflation. Seems dubious to me that should be our goal situation.

When people talk about lack of houses, they mean houses in a neighborhood where they're more likely to have non-troublesome neighbors. But even in the typical "bad" neighborhood, most of the residents are non-troublesome. So, if we could more effectively reign in the jerks, that would probably help a lot for middle class housing issues.

I know how to rein in the jerks, stop enforcing the law. That way everyone with a job will move away, real estate values will crash, and the democratic base can become squatters. Joe Biden solves another problem. Mortgages in the mid 80s were 16%, so rates are still comparatively low, but people of today think a hangnail is a social security disability claim, so of course 7.5% is cause for hysteria. The best thing is that unemployment is historically low so people can get more work and pay more, unlike the 6.5% to double digit unemployment of the early and mid 80s. To the young and their housing problems, a big ole: WAH.

THE UNDENIABLE REALITY IS THAT:

The collusion of business and politicians along with celebrities benefit from their American System of Government.

Everyone knows that the wealthy didn’t earn their wealth by working hard and being honest.

It is the sufferings of the many that pay for the life of opulence and luxuries of the few.

A good just human society is one that assures that no individual is entirely without the means of housing and sustenance, and no individual has inordinate wealth.

God damn some of you old farts are so out of touch. Is anyone listening to what Gammanu95 and Sinclair are saying? They’re absolutely right. The younger generation is screwed unless mom and dad are helping them out.

Let’s do some quick math.

Gen Xer here - getting out of college and buying a house turn of the century - 2000s.

My tuition started at $650 a semester - when I graduated it was around $1,050. Today it’s $10,000 a semester - same school. I graduated with zero debt, most kids today are graduating minimum $40k in debt unless they have affluent parents. They’re screwed even before the enter the job market.

Yes, interest rates are relatively the same. But nobody mentions that a house cost at the minimum double what they did when Gen Xrs were entering this point of their life. Insurance has doubled. Materials have probably gone up probably 200%.

That’s awesome that fast food workers are making double what they did back then (sarcasm). Have teachers, physical therapists, accountants salaries doubled in that time period too? No, they haven’t. How are these young people going to make it now? Our government (either side) certainly isn’t helping them any. Republicans seems to only support the rich and the democrats seem to only want to help import immigrants. Change my mind!

Responding to @25 - High end new construction in south Florida is something of an anomaly. Buyers in this market aren’t affected by mortgage rates, and if they are, they know that their home will appreciate at a rate 2X whatever they’re paying in mortgage interest.

^ it might be something of an anomaly yet this isn’t the only part of the country where this is happening, it’s happening in Utah, Colorado, Idaho, even in Texas, not that I’m claiming it’s the same all over, but it’s more than an anomaly. BTW all new housing starts are up by 18.5% not just luxury housing, so there’s an obviously huge demand, and its not being met.

^Factually false:

Because facts matter: Housing starts are forecast to rise 2.7% to 1.46 million units in 2024

1. A double-digit jump in single-family starts is expected to offset a sharp drop in multifamily construction
2. In February 2024, housing starts in the US soared 10.7% month-over-month to an annualized rate of 1.521 million, after falling by 12.3% in January, and beating forecasts of 1.425 million, amid a persistent shortage of previously owned houses ipropertymanagement.com

Housing costs increase faster than slight declines in interest rates, making rentals more affordable than SFH goldmansachs.com

Folks, this is your tax dollars at work. This is what happens when the democrat party is more concerned with giving free money to illegal aliens, payouts to Iran, handouts to Haiti, pork money to the LBTQIA@!!~~@$^and tells the everyday tax-paying American to screw themselves.

Yeah housing prices are awful. But good thing a few years ago, during Covid, people collectively have figured out how to make work-from-home feasible. And since then, office workers have now been permanently moving to areas that already have homes available and don’t have to be concentrated in centrally located metro areas to have access to those jobs. And ever since the office workers have been settled in their new homes, the individuals who work jobs that require face-to-face contact have also adjusted and also moved into the communities that previously had a declining population.And even if there aren’t enough incentives to build non-luxury homes. ,thanks to people being able to spread out more, younger people without families can help each other build their own tiny homes communities on cheaper land.

It sucks for all the people who have their residential and commercial property portfolios that are taking a hit. And with more empty spaces in those cities, some homeless people have started squatting in those buildings. But at least most people are starting to do better now. And the cities can focus on improving their public transportation systems and make their communities more walkable.

Thank goodness we told the crybabies who screamed about return-to-office to get fucked 😊

For those of you insisting that Gen X / Millennials will be the first generations to be poor than their parents, I'm highly skeptical. I would love to see a scholarly citation or two that supports this claim.

Beyond that there's a lot of other disinformation in this thread right now. Inflation does not "continue to climb", in fact, it's been steady this year after peaking in 2022. tradingeconomics.com

And @twentyfive is right that interest rates are not historically high, and in fact they were probably too low for too long, which may have contributed to recent inflation. We've basically had near-zero interest rates since the start of the great recession, I think that's economically unhealthy, especially in conjunction with the federal deficit exploding under Trump's watch during the pandemic in 2020, and probably was the biggest contributor to inflation. bipartisanpolicy.org

We need to get the government out of the business of handing out money to banks, even if it means people will pay more for a home.

@Puddy Tat69

From the US Dept of Labor Causes of current round of inflation “So, from this research, the authors find that three main components explain the rise in inflation since 2020: volatility of energy prices, backlogs of work orders for goods and service caused by supply chain issues due to COVID-19, and price changes in the auto-related industries.

BTW inflation has come down, that doesn’t make the prices lower it just slows the rate at which they go up. If prices were to suddenly drop to pre-covid levels we’d have a whole new set of problems even more severe than our current situation, called deflation do some reading you’ll see how that would be.

As far as getting more housing constructed figure out where the construction companies will find workers to build in anyone’s backyard, they can’t fulfill the work that is already contracted.

As far as taking over an existing mortgage they’ll need a large amount to make up the difference in price, if they can even find a person willing to allow their assumption of the loan, and have the lender agree to the swap.

If we want to make housing more affordable, actually build some over the objections of white progressive NIMBYs, right in their backyards.

I agree with this, except for the attribution of NIMBYism to progressivism. There are plenty of right-wing NIMBYs too. In the liberal stronghold I live in, Republicans and right-wingers dominate the NIMBY scene in our local politics. NIMBYism is a scourge that taints both sides of the aisle.

Regardless, there's no fucking question that the solution to housing prices is just to build more housing. It's simple and basic economics of supply and demand.

Talking about "inflation coming down" is deceptive. The damage has already been done and can't be reversed. "I put out part of the fire I set," well you're still an arsonist.

I mean, you're right in the sense that inflation stabilizing doesn't mean prices go back to normal. Eggs, milk, gas, and lap dances still cost more in 2024 than they did in 2020. At the same time, I don't think we want prices to return to 2020 levels, because that would require deflation which is also dangerous economically.

Regardless, it's still inaccurate to say inflation continues to climb. The fact is that it has stabilized to just above the 2% rate that the fed targets.

Biden himself says interest rate cuts were "delayed by a month" but who believes that economically illiterate dumbass on anything? Smarter people are talking about rate INCREASES now.

I don't know what you're referring to when you say Biden delayed rate cuts, but the simple fact is: it wasn't his decision.

The fed, by design, operates independently from the White House, and it's currently run by a Trump appointee, Jerome Powell. If you want to criticize someone for failing to act sooner, you should be criticizing Powell, not Biden.

The biggest lever the president has to pull regarding inflation is spending. Debts and deficits are inflationary, full stop. Presidents who sign budgets into law that increase our debt contribute to future inflation, full stop.

Biden's hand over fist spending, particularly on green nonsense with no demonstrable ROI, is correlated.

I think you're referring here to the "Inflation Reduction Act", one of Biden's two major legislative victories. (The other being the Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill.) The Inflation Reduction Act was passed in the house as the "Build Back Better Act" and also incorporated elements of the "Green New Deal", so I think this is what you mean when you say "green nonsense with no demonstrable ROI".

I think reasonable people can disagree about the merits of the IRA, however, I don't know why any informed person would claim this bill is inflationary. The CBO score for this bill projects that it will result in a "net decrease in the deficit totaling $90 billion over the 2022-2031 period." cbo.gov

In contrast, Trump's signature legislative victory was the Tax Cut and Jobs Act, which added between $1-2 trillion to the federal deficit. taxpolicycenter.org

But... maybe I'm missing something or I'm misinformed. When you refer to Biden's "hand over fist spending", what, specifically, are you talking about?

Inflation in Jan 2024: 3.1% Inflation in Feb 2024: 3.2% Inflation in Mar 2024: 3.5% cbsnews.com

RonJax, you say this isn't a rise in inflation? The Fed says it is. There is a reason gold keeps hitting record high lately.

I assume you made a typo when referring to Gen X because those folks are 44 to 59 and have children in Gen Y and Gen Z, and possibly grandchildren in Gen Z. Polling of Gen Y and Gen Z don't show much optimism for the future. cnbc.com

We need to eliminate the deductions and loopholes that the wealthy and connected use to dodge taxes.

Agreed on this point.

Inflation occurred under Biden and not Trump.

Right, so we also agree on this. Just like I'm sure we would agree that pandemic happened under Trump. And I'm sure you'd agree that just because the pandemic happened on Trump's watch doesn't make it his fault.

I think where we disagree is whose actions whose actions were more detrimental to inflation Trump, or Biden.

CBO scores are notoriously gamed, and inaccurate particularly as far as increased revenue collection

OK, so if you don't like the evidence I've presented, present your own. You keep making the argument that Biden caused inflation, what evidence do you have for this claim?

@sinclair, I honestly hadn't read that it was rising again, thanks for the point and the source.

And RE: Gen X, you're right that was a typo and I meant Gen Z / Millennials. And I don't know what Gen Y is, is that after Gen Z?

And thank you for the read on Gen Z and their economic prospects.

Every generation THINKS they're going to be worse off than their parents. As a Gen Xer we were famous for our youthful cynicism, but things are mostly turning out well for my generation.

I think there's no question, Gen Z has had a tougher go. Pandemic school, post-pandemic job market, and post-pandemic inflation are all challenges unlike what any previous generation faced, except maybe the Greatest Generation.

The real question is in the long run Gen Z will be vindicated for their cynicism. I think they'll turn out to be better off than their parents, regardless their current vibes and the very real short-term impediments to their prosperity. The auto-catalytic nature of invention and the steady march of human progress are pretty powerful things and they always seem to win in the long run.

I'm pretty dubious about government subsidies to particular industries, whether it's Biden's direct subsidies, or Trump's tariffs. It's tricky to use tariffs to push up manufacturing wages, because that risks job losses due to more automation.

If you support Trump's policies, you better be really sure about it. Because once the "the election was stolen unless I win" guy is in power, you'll have to live with them permanently. Whether they work or not.

In grocery stores, you see more name brand than store brand stuff on the shelves, even though the name brand stuff is often twice as much. In Europe, you see lots of small, manual transmission cars. Makes it hard for me to see inflation as any sort of existential crisis. Or a bigger issue than all the people we've got sleeping outside on the ground, in the cold and rain.

Y'all should stop fighting about politics on a strip club site, especially in the front room. But, in the spirit of the original post. Yes, low inventory in desirable areas and high interest rates makes it hard to move.

BUT, maybe there is a bright side to all this? Maybe America's mayors can look at all that empty commercial real estate and make it easier for new strip clubs to open? (I mean, I know they won't, but we can hope)

Y'all should stop fighting about politics on a strip club site, especially in the front room

@blah, you’re right and cheers to vacant commercial properties becoming strip clubs

The ship has sailed. The sun has set. The fat lady has sung. The sky is falling. but I think there's still hope...

"Wages keep going up. Inflation keeps coming down. Inflation has dropped from 9 percent to 3 percent — the lowest in the world and trending lower. The landing is and will be soft."
President Biden (March 7, 2024)

Wait until the Trump tax cuts expire and then watch whiney bitch progressives complain poor people are paying more taxes.

@Puddy ‘You have to be pretty dense or willfully blind to believe any sort of administration propaganda’

Does that statement apply across the board or just to Joe Biden?

@25 Does that statement apply across the board or just to Joe Biden?

It applies across the board to democrats, in general.

I see you fellas are indoctrinated as well, Trumps administration never told you the truth either, but let’s face facts, Powell was first appointed to the Fed by Obama, elevated to chairman by Trump, and retained by Biden. Presidents have no real control over monetary policy, haven’t since the Fed was created in the early years of the Twentieth Century ( not sure but I believe the Fed was created in 1915, or thereabouts) the only control over the economy that a president has is the budget. Just to clarify this discussion The Federal Reserve Bank is autonomous and controls the money supply, not Biden, nor Trump, the mistakes that were made were made by Jerome Powell, independently of the president he served. If you don’t agree with this than there’s really nothing to discuss.

Under the 1913 Federal reserve act Presidents can remove the chairman of the Fed for cause, so to say Presidents have no control is not true.

apple.news Lest anyone thinks inflation #’s reported are real in time, they’re not. Considering services inflation is what’s propelling the #’s, and the fact that shelter costs make up 1/3 of the readings, inflation affects everyone differently. Has everyone suddenly become a renter??!! Also, shelter costs lag 18-24 months in reporting in real time. Translation, what we are seeing is why has happened nearly 2 years ago. The fight against inflation is basically over, but wages haven’t kept up, yet. This imbalance is working its way through the system, and rent prices have leveled off for a year and will reflect in the CPI #s going forward. Even the fed has stated so, in spite of political pundits thinking it’s not.

Bottom line, people like me and many established working class individuals have been affected, but adjust easier than the marginalized, and my standard of living hasn’t been reduced at all. In fact, I’d venture to say those in my similar situation have gained in prosperity due to owning appreciating assets(real estate, stocks, bonds), therefore being in a better standing economically. Yet tha doesn’t grab headlines in the media like the woe is me victim culture. Most people are react in knee jerk fashion, not understanding things in totality, they’d rather complain as it is the low hanging fruit to validation, ie misery loves company. I still pay cash for everything; cars, vacations, groceries, lap dances, etc. I finance nothing and it took me 20 years of working my ass off to live below my means to get to this place in life. The media doesn’t want to point out that a large majority of people in the US have also done the same and are doing fine, which is why we can pay elevated prices, but those increases have basically stalled the past 18-24 months, stripping out shelter costs. Now get off my lawn!!

A President needs cause to dismiss a Reserve Chairman, which means grounds other than disagreement with policy. However, since the position is a presidential nomination approved by the Senate, I would think that the Senate and Congress have abilities to censure and impeach the Reserve Chairman for many things including gross incompetence, and POTUS could request the Chairman to resign but not necessarily expect obedience.

However, Jerome Powell is not responsible for the mess, although it is his job to help manage it. Our government is spending too damned much money. Paul Ryan's congress forced President Trump to sign another last minute Omnibus spending bill or have a shut down while controlling Congress and the White House. Pandemic Panic led to massive money handouts. Putin Panic and President Biden's broken border has led to massive payouts to foreign governments and illegal aliens. The lunatic lefties have dragged insane green regulations into our government which continues to drive up the costs we pay daily and degrade our quality of life.

The libs of TUSCL will be triggered, but the solution is conservative policies. Policies guided by sound reason and logic grounded in the science of math and finance. Ukraine is not a vital national security interest. Taiwan is. China is a mortal enemy whom we must decouple from. The Indian Ocean and middle east are too volatile to rely on for our energy and so much outsourcing. We need to onshore so much to bring quality jobs and support our neighbors and our native countrymen. Close the borders until we have sustainable and controlled immigration system. Deny foreign governments from purchasing American land, farms, and resources. Balance investment in green energy with domestic fossil production to protect our economy and quality of life. Pass a balanced budget amendment to the US Constitution with firm penalties for Congress and POTUS failing to do their duty. That last idea is the biggest hurdle. Our elected officials view their offices as careers and entitlements and not as public service with a solemn duty to our heritage and descendants. They refuse to make the hard decisions that may impact their status as a ruling class. Term limits.

@puddy

We agree on this:

Meanwhile, deficit spending is a known inflationary policy.

But this sentence you wrote is blatant mischaracterization of what I wrote, and of the evidence I've provided:

You admit it yourself, above. IRA = deficit spending = inflation.

The IRA, according the CBO link I provided, will result in a NET DECREASE in deficit spending of $90 BN.

I'm trying to have this discussion in good faith, and to that end, I've provided evidence to back my claims and also asked repeatedly pressed you for evidence you can provide that Biden's policies were inflationary.

And you haven't provided any evidence, just vibes, and the reductive insistence that because Biden was president when inflation peaked his policies were to blame. We might as well blame Trump for the pandemic, Bush for 9/11, and FDR for the attack on Pearl Harbor.

Every sensible economist I've read points to multiple causes of inflation, which Biden had nothing to do with: the fact that the deficit was already high at the start of the pandemic due to the Trump's massive tax cuts. Trump's tariffs were inflationary. The massive pandemic recovery spending measures that were enacted under Trump were inflationary. Supply-chain issues due to the post-pandemic restart were a huge problem. (And yes, for sure, the war in Ukraine isn't helping inflation either, given that Ukraine was once one of the top agricultural exporters in the world, and food prices are a big part of the CPI.)

The only people blaming Biden for high inflation are right wing media. If I want to consume right-wing disinformation, I don't need TUSCL for that, I could just go watch Fox News, OAN, or go on Facebook to see what my misinformed boomer relatives are posting about.

Have the last word, I think if you are not going to provide any evidence to back your claims and you're going to mischaracterize the evidence I've presented, it's not worth my time to have the conversation.

"the prediction is the Feds may not lower interest rates at all this year."

That is not even a definitive statement let alone a prediction. Just keep your eye on inflation. Other indicators of economic growth are looking positive so far this year, for example employment numbers are strong and also the S&P 500 is up around 10%. Just a couple indications that things are moving in the right direction. But the Fed officials are not going to cut rates unless they feel confident about inflation. When those numbers go down, we will see rate cuts. The first will probably happen later this year assuming the economy cools off and inflation follows suit and cools off too. So you're looking at July 31 (if we are being optimistic and inflation eases by then) or November 7 if we're being less optimistic but still not pessimistic. I'll be disappointed if rates still aren't cut after their November meeting.

As far as "many people" saying that soon interest rates will go down to 2020 levels (record lows, under 3%), who do you know that is saying that? I don't know a single person IRL, from Economist to Realtor or anyone in between, who predicts rates to drop back to 3% within the next couple years. Seriously, I don't know a single person who knows/follows the market and actually thinks that. Even the most optimistic lenders I know are not predicting anything under 5. I personally am predicting rates to be around 5.5% by Q1 2026! Anything lower than that would pleasantly surprise me.

@PT Yes, my point was, people who are truly falling through the cracks are the crisis. For most people, their bigger problem is not trying or knowing how to spend their money wisely. A sliver lining, if inflation would teach people to get value for their money, and not pick a vehicle primarily to be their symbolic giant penis. I suppose, if we're going to be a bunch of panicky pants-shitters, it makes sense our leader should be a guy who is apparently oblivious to the fact that he smells like he's continuously shitting himself.

Trump sought to set aside the election results, not find actual counting errors and correct them. He was only stopped because he couldn't find enough people who would go along with it to fill the necessary positions in the military and the Department of Justice. His supporters are finding such people to serve in his next administration.

The majority of illegal immigrants are unskilled or semi-skilled. If we kick them out, employers will have to pay much more to replace them. If they can't be replaced, that will lead to lower production. How do you think that will affect inflation? If we accept paying more for low-skill labor, why don't we raise the minimum wage, to attract legal residents to take those jobs? With Mexicans at least, there's a lot of evidence that they deport themselves when they can't do better here moneywise than in Mexico.

^ "Trump sought to set aside the election results, not find actual counting errors and correct them."

You didn’t like that, but you accuse anyone who refuses to vote for him of “Trump Derangement Syndrome “

You guys got brass fucking balls, anyone who votes for him is fucking deranged

^ You believe he tried to steal an election but you're going to vote for him anyway, that's deranged.

^Almost as deranged as voting for a senile moron with dementia causing wars all over the globe like Biden. Under fat loudmouth Trump there was no war in Gaza, there was no war in Ukraine, we didn't run away from Afghanistan, Iran wasn't shooting missiles at Israel, Yemen wasn't sinking commercial shipping, China wasn't threatening Taiwan every day, China was trying to steal from the Philippines and Viet Nam every day. How fucked up are democrats? No words can adequately describe them.

As far as the people here citing government statistics to prove that inflation is under control and not as terrible as every non-progressive knows? Fuck you. All of you. The exact same people that progressives pretend to support are always the ones they fuck over the most.

Just dumb, SkiDumb. Constant rage aholic ramblIng on like BLM did during the 2020 riots. You’ll get cancer holding onto that much hate, projecting your feelings, like they matter…..

@PT Trump waited for mote than 2 hours before making a statement urging the violent-but-loved protesters to stand down. His administration was equally slow to get backup to the Capitol Police. So you want to claim that wasn't malicious, merely incompetent? Yet, somehow, when it comes to the economy, he'll turn into a genius, who will give us price rollbacks to 2020, without causing a deflationary spiral?

I remember all the hate Reagan got during the early 80s economic crisis. To the point of people saying they wished Hinkley had better aim. But that situation was set in motion when Carter appointed Volker as Fed Chair. Both Carter and Reagan could see no alternative, than to swallow some bitter medicine to end the stagflation of the 70s. In general, the current state of the economy is not simply a result of current policies. It's years, even decades, in the making.

Trump isn't qualitatively worse than politicians in general, but much worse quantitatively. He doesn't just stop with voter suppression and gerrymandering. He wants to "find" votes, and unnecessarily force presidential elections into the House. I don't see how it makes sense to accept the risk that implies, based on some crazy hope he can manage the economy in a way NO President ever has. The best we've done in my lifetime was when Dole wrestled Clinton with his one arm, and we actually briefly had a small budget surplus, with decent inflation and employment numbers.

The key points with illegal immigration are:

1. It's not a major cause of crime statistically.
2. Only a very small percentage of illegal immigrants commit welfare fraud.
3. They're doing what most people would do in their situation (if they had as much balls).
4. Trying to make it nearly impossible to sneak across the border fails any serious cost-benefit analysis.
5. Expedited mass deportation of illegal immigrants could cause the worst economic crisis we've seen since the 30s. We need to explore the issue with pilot programs. Like, pick a few farmers, and subsidize the wages they pay so that they're high enough to attract legal residents to do the harvesting. Based on the results gotten, we'll can decide how much deporting we should do, and how many illegal immigrants need to be converted into legal guest workers.
6. Do you want me to lose the will to live? That's what will happen if my Cuban favs who are waiting for their asylum hearing get deported.

Lets refute the idiocy posted above: 1) Governmental statistics are what liars resort to when they try to trick people, making them meaningless; 2) All immigrants legal and otherwise collect public benefits at a rate of 2-1 over the native born, so mentionin g only welgfare cheats is a straw man argument and the fact is that every immigrabt costs the American taxpayer money, with the only question being: How much? 3) Lying, cheating and stealing from others is what criminals do, not what most people do, but to a progressive crime is ok, as long as you are from certain groups, hom they look down upon, as they pretend to help; 4) Start harming illegals, taling their children away and sending them home alone to suffer. Make sure it is all over the news. That is a start. Shoot a few coming across and things will snowball; 5) in conjunction with getting rid of very single illegal, make social security disability the disbality/inability level for welfare and then with the 90% who no longer qualify for the dole, the jobs get filled; and 6) Unlike progressives I don't need to use and abuse the poor to get sex. When Cubans are gone, I will take up tennis. Hint at the mendacity of some: Pretending a budget surplus does or means anything. It just means you didn't overspend by the amount you intended, not that the deficit was reduced.

@PT

"The only people blaming Biden for high inflation are right wing media." False. David Lynch of the Washington Post (right wing media my left nut) says 3-4% of inflation (in 2022) was directly attributable to Biden's American Rescue Plan.

I actually agree with you that the ARP is one of many causes of inflation. It added $1.9T to the federal debt and that's inflationary. I think I acknowledged in prior posts that pandemic recovery measures under both Trump and Biden played a major role in igniting inflation. FWIW, I've also read the David Lynch Article you're referring to, and largely agree with it's conclusion:

Biden’s rescue plan made inflation worse but the economy better | washingtonpost.com

Lynch also acknowledges the major role several of Trump's rescue plans, including the $2.1T dollar CARES Act. What's odd to me is that you see only the American Rescue Plan, when the reality is there were several large COVID aid packages, most of them under Trump (whom you do not seem hold to account in the slightest.)

According to the US government, there were six major COVID relief packages signed into law \ pandemicoversight.gov:

1. The Coronavirus Preparedness and Response Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2020 (Total $7.8B)
2. The Families First Coronavirus Response Act (Total $15.4B)
3. The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, (CARES Act) (Total $2.1T)
4. Paycheck Protection Program and Health Care Enhancement Act (Total $483B)
5. The Coronavirus Response and Relief Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2021 Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 (Total $900B)
6. The American Rescue Plan of 2021 (Total $1.9T)

Trump signed 1-5. Biden signed number 6. Roughly $3.6 trillion for Trump and $1.9 for Biden. Why are you honing in on Biden's pandemic spending as the sole cause of inflation?

And we haven't even gotten into the worthiness of any of these aid packages. My personal opinion is that there was probably some amount of COVID aid and stimulus deficit spending was necessary, even if it meant paying the inflation price later. I think we overshot the mark, but fortunately not as bad as many of our international friends (where inflation has been worse).

I think some of the spending was particularly odious, especially the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP), whose loan forgiveness provisions made it effectively a cash transfer to business owners/shareholders. You could argue this was necessary maybe for restaurateurs retail business owners, but the PPP applied to every industry, even in places like tech, finance and health care where shareholders made a ton of money in 2020 without sprinkling PPP funds on top.

You talked earlier about the wealthy paying their fare share, the PPP was basically just giving the wealthy money. But this was legislation signed by Trump, not Biden.

So to tie this into the original point of who is to blame for inflation, when we account for pandemic deficit spending, we need to account for the fact that the vast majority of it happened under Trump. And not only did most pandemic spending happen under Trump, it happened just after he'd passed one of the largest tax cuts in history for the wealthy, adding trillions to the federal debt.

I would think inflation is a topic that would unite people across the spectrum.

Presidents don't cause inflation. Trump spent a lot, and Biden spends even more. There is no fiscal conservatism anymore. Nobody seems to care.

For those thinking you have inflation figured out, please look at the correlation between money supply and a measure of inflation like CPI or PCE. For a decade plus (post GFC to 2019, let's call it), the world tried to stoke inflation. ZIRP for a decade, couldn't get inflation up after the GFC. Money printer go brrrr did NOT equal more inflation until governments fucked the world by shutting down amid a massive overreaction. Then a massive injection of liquidity in March 2020 combined with supply chain issues lit it all on fire.

I'm not suggesting that higher spending and loose monetary policy doesn't contribute to inflation, but they did that for a decade and inflation went nowhere. So, please don't pretend to understand the multitude of variables which contribute to an interconnected global economy. This is not a univariate system we're working with here. It's complicated. And no one truly understands it.

For all time, the public will be easily fooled by simplistic thinking like "the economy was good when this guy was president, so, he must be the reason." Please, don't be so naive. Other things are more simple, like "my guy won't hire people who will prosecute crime or illegal immigration, so they're higher". But the economy requires more nuance than that.

@PT so you support Trump, just none of his policies?

Trump's "Remain In Mexico" policy was questionably legal. I don't think Biden fired border patrol agents, or tore down any walls or fences on the border. And Trump recently blocked a bill to increase resources for border security.

If you're going to deny that Trump blatantly pressured Pence to illegally block the certification of the election results, I leave it to you to decide who would be the best President in your dream world.

So feel free to carry on with the Trump vs Biden America yadda yadda yadda but just a PSA to everyone…be sure to watch your alcohol intake from the club when driving home from the club and don’t crash your car into anything. The worst of the inflation seems to be coming from motor vehicle insurance, motor vehicle repair, and hospital services. 🫣

reddit.com

@PT so you're going to put quotes around half a sentence? It's extra sketchy when you don't even put in a ...?

When, from watching Fox News (and apparently little else) you think you know better than a kid's parents and doctor, that's a very sad and sick dream world. Some of the kids will have regrets as adults. Bound to happen, whether the treatment is allowed or blocked.

Does Trump have the Proud Boys on standby to unify us all?

People blindly had faith that Biden could quickly end the pandemic. Now they have blind faith Trump can lower prices and interest rates. Maybe the second time's the charm.

@nice it's all due to the distracted driving from you not wearing baggy shirts with a high neck line.