I've been to 11 of the clubs on the revised Top 40, and they were "rockin' good". However, we all know Adelita is a different kind of place, more like the cocktail lounge for a whorehouse. Also, I think there are regional differences in what consititutes a great club. A couple of clubs in Massachusetts are very highly rated, but I think that is because most clubs in MA are low mileage, so a decent club looks great in comparison. The same cannot be said of clubs in FL or TX, where generally high mileage means a Top 40 club is very good indeed.
Only Founder knows for sure, but if the new formula eliminates some of the bias from the "one hit wonders" or "shills", that is great!