There's a club that I go to and only see one dancer. If she needs a title or description, she's a CF, 1 of 6 CFs. I really don't go see her too much because I bounce between a handful clubs. Over the last 3 years, I've probably got about 25 dances from this favorite. She knows I come to see her and I won't be getting dances from anyone else. I'm sown up tight with her.
I stopped in to see her a few weeks ago and she wasn't there. Oh fuck. Now what? She texted her schedule a few days earlier. It's her scheduled day. I did the only thing I could think of, I feel in love with a different dancer there. Yep, I've got a new favorite.
I've got the new favorites number and she lets me know if old favorite is working or not. I have gone to see her twice since.
I'm not going to play that game anymore. I'm just going to let the chips fall where they may. It's going to be interesting tonight, they're both in the club. I'm either going to enjoy both or just the new favorite. Old favorite will get to decide if she wants to be second. Old favorite is super catty even though she claims to keep to herself. I predict she will ignore me and claw new favorite's eyes out.
Or maybe I'll get a smokin hot double dance. Ha!
I feel like I'm ambushing them but should I care or do something different?


If you read here you know my general thoughts on this: I think guys should stop be intimidated and scared of dancers, the fear customers have of "true" jealousy and the like is completely mis-placed, and I always pick "respectful but clear and direct" over "passive aggressive or sneaking around".
In short, here's what I did last time I was in your situation. I walked in to see CF2. CF1 sees me and makes a beeline to me. I smile and say hi and give her a hug, make a few seconds of small talk -- she's a person who has provided me with plenty of good times, no reason to be disrespectful -- and then I say, "I have an appointment with CF2 today, but it's awesome seeing you, I'll talk to you later". I delivered that statement with a smile, as if it were just a matter-of-fact thing, but with eye contact and confidence. That was that. There's no exciting ending to this story, she got the message. No reason to sneak around having CF2 text me when CF1 isn't there, no reason to think in melodramatic terms such as "let the chips fall where they may". There's no chips to fall anywhere, you the customer are moving on. And my general experience is, as long as you don't act like a weak little bitch, that will be that -- if you're all shy and weak over it, she'll sense that, and manipulate you however she has to to keep your wallet.
In short, I think you're thinking about this entirely wrong, and making it far more of a big deal than it is. Any drama CF1 causes -- and I predict she'll cause none -- is not your problem, you do not owe her everlasting patronage. This whole thing is a non-issue; the idea that it's some delicate situation is in your head.