DILEMMA!

Neither would be a major consideration for me. That said, if they were, breasts would be first.

Neither. ATF status is based on a lot more than any physical attributes.

Shadow - Bingo!

That's a tough one, 10inches. I would lean toward 2) myself but to each his own.

Which one does swallows?

If you have to ask which one you aren't there yet. You will know when one bcomes a favorite.

I'd pick the ass. Although both are mostly ornamental. A sexy ass makes me want to fuck. Nice tits make me want to squeeze.

Assuming you have two near identical personalities between two women, with the difference being tits versus ass. I would say it depends on how much your ATF will let you do with either. I have known a few women that won't let their tits/nipples be touched much; let alone titty fucked. I've never had any problems with unlimited ass grabbing.

Now getting Greek/anal is a different story.

Yes, ATF eligibility is based on many criteria besides NICE Tits & Ass.

This reminds me of this dancer I saw a week ago. She had quite possibly one of the best bodies I've seen in my life, 5' 6" brunette, about 120, big nice ass and full, firm breasts, half-dollar brown nipples, toned, tan body, muscular thighs, the kind if she kickboxed would leave you blue and limping the next day. Basically, a classic pin-up. I have never had sex with a woman this well built, and possibly could have, I don't know. But, she was a pouty, miserable, litte woman with a bad game and lies I couldn't fall for. And I was drunk and not in the mood for it. I told her it was a shame too, such an incredible body was given to such a pain in the ass!

I don't choose an ATF, she chooses me. :)

More seriously, physical attributes weren't at the top of the list for my ATF, nor is it so for the girl who is currently viing for that spot. In fact, in both instances, there are girls with better asses and boobs inthe same club. They don't come close in personality, though.

I'd pick number 1.

Tits, baby!

(You can always buy her some tits, right?)

Wrong! Fake asses are available too.

3- the stripper who lets me fuck her up her ass every time

Boobs. Only because I have nice boobs. Everyone I work with comments on how awesome my boobs are. Is give my boobs a 10. I'd give my butt a 7.

Answer: Yes. (Oh wait, I have to choose?)

Stiletto25: "I'd give my butt a 7."

Nah, it's too easy.

I have to agree with those that say it is more than just physical appearance. There has to be a personality as well for an ATF.

Boobs definitely. See my profile pics for some of many faves over the years. Most of them--I don't even know what their butts looks like!

@Stiletto:Hmm.That makes you a 8.5 if my math is right. :)