Almost everything removing the incentive for strippers to hustle for tips is bad for the PLs.
A more boring discussion though is identified near the end of the article- the new rule incentivizes employers to pay dishwashers and untipped positions with tips. This is the lede. This rule saves money for hotel and restaurant employers. Sound like any presidents you know? Those employers have to comply with minimum wage laws, and the minimum wage is going up in a lot of states in the next few years. In some places as high as $15 per hour. If an employer was able to transfer tips from servers to dishwashers, the employer shifts the compensation burden to pay the dishwasher minimum wage in some large part to the rest of the staff. The employer must still comply with minimum wage law, but its share of that burden is reduced.
I don’t know if it’s good or bad. I do feel confident that it is upsetting the existing system and is cutting costs for the employer and redistributing wealth from the tipped employees to all employees. Doesn’t sound like capitalism at all.