For the unpublished reviews, I don't see an opportunity for the reviewer to add a comment or pose a question. That was a helpful feature of the separate unpublished review section.
I'm not getting what Electronman is saying about the unpublished reviews section. When I look at the unpublished reviews page I still see a comment box.
I see there are "submitted" (unpublished) and "reviewed" (published) all listed in reviews now. But I just submitted one and the site is giving me the option of rejecting or publishing (adjudicating my own review) 😂
I like the added visibility of having unpublished reviews display at the top of the published reviews list but I do think it may cause some confusion, especially when the UI for the adjudicators is different in the new view.
@founder overall the UI improvements to the mobile site have been amazing but the issue with incorrect club logos displaying past the first page of reviews has been persistent for a while. It's not that important but it can make scrolling a bit disorienting.
When we had a separate "unpublished" review section, there was a comment box that you could use to offer suggestions for revisions, a helpful feature for reviews that were rejected. I don't see a comment box on the unpublished reviews with the current design.
Comments
last commentfeature?
Log in to vote
I think I like it, just put all the stuff in the same place. More folks will vote that way.
Log in to vote
It'd be hilarious if founder added a recall feature on reviews. For a day or two at least.
Log in to vote
For the unpublished reviews, I don't see an opportunity for the reviewer to add a comment or pose a question. That was a helpful feature of the separate unpublished review section.
Log in to vote
If you approve a review, you can ask a question in the comments when it's published
Log in to vote
I'm not getting what Electronman is saying about the unpublished reviews section. When I look at the unpublished reviews page I still see a comment box.
Log in to vote
I see there are "submitted" (unpublished) and "reviewed" (published) all listed in reviews now. But I just submitted one and the site is giving me the option of rejecting or publishing (adjudicating my own review) 😂
Log in to vote
I like the added visibility of having unpublished reviews display at the top of the published reviews list but I do think it may cause some confusion, especially when the UI for the adjudicators is different in the new view.
@founder overall the UI improvements to the mobile site have been amazing but the issue with incorrect club logos displaying past the first page of reviews has been persistent for a while. It's not that important but it can make scrolling a bit disorienting.
Log in to vote
When we had a separate "unpublished" review section, there was a comment box that you could use to offer suggestions for revisions, a helpful feature for reviews that were rejected. I don't see a comment box on the unpublished reviews with the current design.
Log in to vote
@Electronman The comment box is still there if you click "unpublished reviews" but not if you go to a "submitted" review after clicking reviews.
Log in to vote
Interesting. I completely misinterpreted what was happening. I rejected a couple of reviews because I thought they were duplicates.
Log in to vote