It is your place to critique if you purposely go to unpublished reviews to do that.
No punctuation, no capitalization and no paragraphs make the review very hard to read so it is almost the only reason I’ll reject one. If it’s unreadable it has no value regardless of the content.
Comments
last commentNot really - as long as the content is good - it's a bigger PITA when they don't use any punctuation
Log in to vote
Sometimes I can only get through a few sentences before getting annoyed by it.
Log in to vote
Damn this is a topic we haven’t debated in
Three days
Log in to vote
Really? The last time I remember debating over acceptable reviews, it was because of lollipops or something.
Log in to vote
Yes I reject as incoherent if it's one long run on paragraph.
Log in to vote
As a former teacher it’s funnier than hell to see how some people murder the English language and detract from their tale.
Instead I try to follow the story for the entertainment or research factor. If it is just a fucked up mess I do press reject with regret.
Log in to vote
Well, if we reject based on grammatical errors, then very few will get approved.
Log in to vote
Never have rejected one. Live and let live. Ain't my place to critique another's opinion. If it's a review that's garbage, I just scroll thru.
Log in to vote
It is your place to critique if you purposely go to unpublished reviews to do that.
No punctuation, no capitalization and no paragraphs make the review very hard to read so it is almost the only reason I’ll reject one. If it’s unreadable it has no value regardless of the content.
Log in to vote