OT: Is this racist?
TheeOSU
FUCK IT!
I'm not defending the heckler in this story, he actually sounded pretty lame and ignorant, but I am wondering if things get to the point that anything said to a black man by a non black man will be considered racist by the media.
Quote from news article..
San Antonio Spurs point guard Patty Mills was the target of a fan’s racially charged taunting during Sunday’s game against the Cleveland Cavaliers.
Mills was at the free throw line late in the fourth quarter when a fan shouted out, “hey Jamaican dog they want their bobsledder back! Hey Mills, Jamaica just called, they want their bobsledder back!”
Question, what there is racially charged?
Yes most Jamaicans are black but Jamaicans are not a race, they are a nationality and I am positive that there are white Jamaicans.
Change the heckle to “hey American dog they want their bobsledder back! Hey Mills, America just called, they want their bobsledder back!”
Is there any racism in that altered quote?
Dogs are not a race.
Bobsledders and bobsleds are not a race.
So calling a guy a Jamaican dog bobsledder is racist?
https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nba/spu…
Quote from news article..
San Antonio Spurs point guard Patty Mills was the target of a fan’s racially charged taunting during Sunday’s game against the Cleveland Cavaliers.
Mills was at the free throw line late in the fourth quarter when a fan shouted out, “hey Jamaican dog they want their bobsledder back! Hey Mills, Jamaica just called, they want their bobsledder back!”
Question, what there is racially charged?
Yes most Jamaicans are black but Jamaicans are not a race, they are a nationality and I am positive that there are white Jamaicans.
Change the heckle to “hey American dog they want their bobsledder back! Hey Mills, America just called, they want their bobsledder back!”
Is there any racism in that altered quote?
Dogs are not a race.
Bobsledders and bobsleds are not a race.
So calling a guy a Jamaican dog bobsledder is racist?
https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nba/spu…
23 comments
And I guess you have the superpower of being able to ascertain unstated intentions.
Just saying Jamaica called and they want their bobsledder back is funny.
"Yes most Jamaicans are black but Jamaicans are not a race, they are a nationality"
Chinese is not a race, it's a nationality. But I guarantee if you were told to close your eyes and picture a Chinese woman, she would be Asian, which is a race. That's just an example, there are plenty more nationalities that almost always represent someone's race.
"and I am positive that there are white Jamaicans."
White people make up less than 1% of Jamaicans. Actually, it is closer to 0% at a whopping 0.2%. So, out of every 1,000 Jamaicans, 2 are white. An extremely small number of white Jamaicans does not in anyway change the commonly held (and true) belief that almost all Jamaicans are black, with over 90% being black, and over 7% of the rest being mixed with black and something else, which rounds out to about 98% of Jamaicans being black or part black. Come on now.
The guy who said those comments is a jerk, but it's sad that so many people don't understand the power of their obnoxious words. If he'd said it to a blue collar Jamaican immigrant here in America, the Jamaican person would probably be offended. I think that's the more important part of this discussion. Patty Mills is a multi millionaire who is an indigenous Australian, so I'm sure he is fine. People have every right to be offended by someone trying to put down their background.
If a person called out to me and said “The WASP’s just called - they want their dog back! You pasty - flat assed - rhythm-less - tennis-playing - fool!” - I’d consider it to be racist too.
As I understand it, it is only racist if it was motivated as a disparaging remark based on one's race.
_____________
I think the original comment referred to a story where elementary-school aged kids who were mimicking Trump and reciting "Build that wall" to Latino and black kids -- which of course had to be stopped.
Someone loony enough to believe that Obama was born in Kenya probably wouldn't understand.
@shadow, imo smoking a pipe is a little bit of a pain in the ass.
Ignore my last comment.