Red Garter Gentlemen's Club
437 S Illinois St Indianapolis, IN 46225

They have no customers, and it seems the thug bouncers are doing their best to keep it that way

VIP Review
Avatar for secretagentman11
VIP
secretagentman11
Feb 21, 2026, 2:02 PM
Dancers
Club Quality
Value
Visited: Thursday Evening

Shitty place. I walked in, paid the $10 cover. The door girl was very concerned about my dress pants and had to make sure they had a zipper and were not sweatpants. First time this has ever happened to me. I sat down close to the stage, and this place was DEPRESSING. Hardly any customers on a late Thursday evening. I don't think I saw anyone getting any dances. The girls were just sitting around. They were about what I expected, I guess (I've been here once before). I mean, I've seen much uglier dancers other places (and also much prettier). There was a somewhat decent looking girl on stage. Don't recall if she ever got topless, but it seemed like she kept dancing for quite a while. Among the positives, there didn't seem to be any drink minimum, and the girls were not pushy at all. Maybe they were all just exhausted and resigned at this point.

 

I got a few dances from a young, ok looking girl (I'm sure you'll be shocked to find out that there were no stunners here). Now this is where it gets really bad. Touching is allowed. But how much touching? You won't really know until the short, fat and ugly thug bouncer is threatening to "knock you the fuck out." Seems you can touch boobs (or at least I was able to), and the girl was putting them in my face. You can touch their butts as well. But apparently, get just a little too close to the buttcrack, and they go ballistic. I didn't even realize how closely I was being watched. (Mind you, it's not like I thought about it at all, because I wasn't even trying to "get away" with anything.) I got a little too close to the buttcrack once, and the dancer made some animal sound and moved my hand away (but didn't say anything). Let me reiterate, I wasn't even trying to bend the rules (whatever they were) or put my hand in there. At some point, I guess I kind of accidentally did it a second time. Again, I wasn't trying to offend her. I probably wasn't even really paying attention to exactly where I was putting my hand. Since touching ass was allowed and I certainly wasn't trying to ram my hand up her asscrack. She again made the same sound and moved my hand away. Again without saying anything. At some point afterwards (it felt like it wasn't right after for some reason), that fat thug came up and immediately threated violence. I would like to point out that this is the first time this has ever happened to me in all the years of going to strip clubs all over America and other countries. There was at least one other place (namely, Polekatz in the Chicago area) were hosts or security told me that I can't touch particular areas, but at least they were reasonably nice about it (note that the dancers themselves made no indication whatsoever that I couldn't touch them like that at that place).

 

I later noticed that fat thug taking a seat closer to the lap dance area when I went there with another girl a bit later. I was apparently the only person here getting dances, so he would move over there when I went there with a girl and leave to sit further away when I left. To clarify, I was getting $25 per song dances. I recall they also have the "Red Room"(?), which is 3 songs for $100, and also a 30 minutes for $300+ option. I have no idea if they watch you closely there as well.

Full review available to VIP members

Unlock thousands of detailed, honest strip club reviews.

300K+ reviews • Trusted community since 1998