Peyton's Play Pen
Closed
3901 2nd Ave Brooklyn, NY 11232

Not bad, but expected more in Brooklyn

VIP Review
Avatar for misterorange
VIP
misterorange
Jan 19, 2020, 1:51 PM
Dancers
Club Quality
Value
Visited: Tuesday Afternoon

Stopped by this place on my way back to Jersey after dropping a friend off at JFK Airport. It's been a lot of years since I mongered in Brooklyn. There used to be a spot called "Mom's" not far from this one that was really grungy and dirty, a real "anything goes" kind of place, so I was hoping this might be similar. Unfortunately it wasn't the case. It's a so-so area and I was a little concerned about parking my car outside, but found a space right across the street so I could go out for a smoke and check on it. The place is kind of long and narrow with a long bar on the right. I guess because it was a weekday, late afternoon, it wasn't busy. Only two other customers, and one left right after I came in. A few girls wandering around, one was a hippo, one was decent, about a 6-1/2 to 7 I'd say, and the 3rd was a very dark skin AA with a hot body and kind of Plain Jane face. That one sat next to me. She was nice and we had a good conversation. Bought her 2 or 3 drinks and then we went for a lap dance. She did a good grind and started getting me hard. By the 2nd song her top was off and she let me suck on what was the best pair of tits I've seen in quite a while. She couldn't have been more than 19 or 20 and those titties were fucking perfect. By the 3rd song it didn't seem like much more was to be had. I asked about extras and I had plenty of money to spend, but she said not in the club and she would give me her number to hook up OTC. Back to the bar, we drank and chatted for another 20 minutes. She gave me her number and then I left. I really wanted to try her for OTC but my better sense told me not to. I've only done that a few times and always with girls I knew pretty well. Maybe I'm too paranoid but I considered the possibility that she might set me up to get jumped and robbed. (She told me she's in East New York and we could meet at her place, so...you know what I mean.) I tossed her number out the window on the Belt Parkway because I know myself pretty well, and I might get drunk some night and then make a bad decision. I wouldn't mind seeing her again at the club, but it's really kind of far and big tolls on the bridges for me to get there not even knowing if she's working. Anyway, the place looks like it could be okay on a busy evening.

Full review available to VIP members

Unlock thousands of detailed, honest strip club reviews.

300K+ reviews • Trusted community since 1998