Pleasure Island Club
Closed
257 NY-17K, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA*

An earlier reviewer called this place...

VIP Review
Avatar for arbeeguy
arbeeguy
Aug 28, 2009, 12:00 AM
Dancers
Club Quality
Value
Visited: Friday Evening

An earlier reviewer called this place a dive. I do not agree. It was not a "HIGH GRADE GENTLEMAN'S CLUB" nor was it a dive. Somewhere in between. If he had called it a brothel, I think I could agree with that. I had a good time here, and spent more than normal, cuz I wanted to check out the possibilities. The girl that I picked for the private dance was very forthright. As we discussed options for the Private room she said, "And I don't fuck. But some of the girls will if you ask." So there. She gave a very very enjoyable CBJ, and I left the club very happy, and about $320 poorer. The room was private, no cameras, and a locked door in front. Decent bench/couch, and free to shed as much clothing as desired (I think she left her g-string around her ankles, which style I emulated. Everything was fine. She was young, sexy, beautiful, great pair of natural tits, firm body.

You can also get nice lap dances in an open area, with plenty of touchy-feely for $25 plus dancer tip. If the tip is OK you can do some discreet pussy-fondling and tittie-sucking in the lap dance area. I think the "$25 + tip" lap dances are a good deal. But I would negotiate and stipulate the size of the so-called tip, and the services available, BEFORE giving the $25 to management. I hate upselling after getting to the lap-dance area or private room.

Here's the way I think the $25 fee (for lap dance) and $150 fee (for private room) works. She will tell you that for a half hour in the locked private room, the house gets $150 (as someone else said, this is non-negotiable -- you or she must hand it to Management before you depart for the private room. She also tells you she just works for tips, but this is not exactly true. She also gets a big cut of that $150. I did not realize this until I was getting ready to go so I have no way to know whether she gets $50 or &75 of your $150, but I'm sure she gets part of it. How can I be sure? I had an interesting discussion with another girl just before I left. I was complaining about Management getting $25 for the lap dance. The pitch they give you there is, $25 goes to management. But she inadvertently told me that she gets a $15 kickback from that $25. Which makes sense if you stop to think about it. If you believe that to get a lap dance with a nice girl, you have to give Management $25, you are going to want to give HER a decent tip in addition to that. If you don't know she's getting $15 of that $25 you are inclined to give her a bigger tip, right? Same logic in the Private room I am sure.

Full review available to VIP members

Unlock thousands of detailed, honest strip club reviews.

300K+ reviews • Trusted community since 1998
An earlier reviewer called this place...